By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions. We in turn value your personal details in accordance with our Privacy Policy.
Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
I think it means you cant have more than a couple of young inexperienced players in a side and go up against players with far more experience even if you can match them for size, " Rochdale’s 27.1 average age masks a sharp generational split: they boast the oldest attacking unit (28.9 yrs, featuring 41-year-old Ian Henderson, 34-year-old Jamie Paterson, and 31-year-old Emmanuel Dieseruvwe) alongside the youngest goalkeeping department (20.8 yrs, led by 19-year-old Brighton loanee Nils Ramming). By contrast, Barnet (26.1 yrs) and York City (26.8 yrs) concentrate their rosters in the 24–29 athletic peak across every line. Salford, Barnet, and York are built around tighter, prime-age cores.
• Top 3 Core XI Average: ~235 career EFL appearances per player • Salford City leads the division—regular starters Will Norris, Luke Garbutt, Will Aimson, Jorge Grant, and Daniel Udoh alone account for over 1,600 combined EFL appearances. • Chesterfield pairs seasoned midfielders Tom Naylor (35, 450+ EFL games) and Liam Mandeville (29, 300+ senior games) with prime-age attackers Josh Koroma and Dilan Markanday. • Barnet boasts the most balanced "prime-age" core—players like Brandon Comley (31), Charlie Lakin (27), Tom Knowles (28), and Idris Kanu (26) all sit squarely in the 200–300 career senior appearances bracket
Comparing the 11 most-used players for each side during the 2026/27 campaign so far, Rochdale's core XI averages ~24.8 years of age and ~130 career EFL appearances per player, whereas Salford City's core XI averages ~28.3 years and ~275 career EFL appearances. That creates a 3.5-year age gap and more than double the EFL experience in Salford’s favor—largely because Rochdale’s heaviest minutes are carried by U21 Premier League loanees and newly promoted signings, while Salford’s regular starters are established Championship and League One veterans.
• Height Advantage: Rochdale held a noticeable physical advantage in height (+4.9 cm on average), anchored by centre-back pairing Aden Flint (197 cm) and Kaiden Wilson (191 cm), which helped them edge the aerial duels 52% to 48%. • Age & Experience: While WhoScored's match centre lists Rochdale's broader matchday squad average slightly higher (27.3)—boosted by 41-year-old substitute Ian Henderson—York City fielded the older starting eleven on the day, featuring seven starters aged 27 or older. • Youth Factor: Both sides started 21-year-old goalkeepers or defenders—Sam Waller (23), Kaiden Wilson (21), Kane Taylor (21), Zain Silcott-Duberry (21), and Dajaune Brown (21) for Rochdale, alongside Alfie McNally (21) and Zak Johnson (21) for York.
Flint and Henderson change the stats, particularly height and experience, we played 4 21 year olds and a 23 year old keeper against York, who had two U21s
Taylors loan is up in January...the vast majority are contracted to the end of this season with 4 or 5 until 27/28... not sure about Allen and Flint but to be honest I think we need their experience for as long as possible. Whatever happens in January , we are looking at another big shake out for next season...
The step up to league 2 is hard...you have to be able to compete physically as the first order of business, only then do you get to play a more technical brand of football. L2 clubs are awash with strapping, 6 foot tall lads, 25 - 30 years old, who can run, tackle and win headers. Add in a potent striker and the means to feed him and you are in with a shout..
The simple statistics tell us we can't defend well enough and can't score enough goals to mitigate a leaky defence. We were in trouble from day one. Finding a manager capable of fixing it is going to be very difficult and probably expensive and thats assuming there is a manager prepared to take on the task.
We now have a 30 game season to get 40+ points, taking us to around 55 and probable L2 survival.. 1.25 per game compared to just under 1 point per game so far so a 25% improvement in results, not at all impossible but it will require an improvement on Brown as striker/ target/ poacher, more minutes for Henderson and at least 1 more striker. And it seems like Dieseruvwe and Rodney are not going to be much help based on 16 games so far, I think National League is their ceiling.....Shutting the back door would also be high on the agenda, 4 at the back or a 3 with wingbacks with some central cover in midfield and above all a sense of playing safe passes, reducing risk and a touch of the old Peter Valentine approach to defending.. " if in doubt hoof it into row Z". Yesterday exposed the whole problem, it started badly , they rescued a potential win and then lost, couldnt even settle for what would have been a decent point The new manager has to be a pragmatist, a good explainer, single minded and prepared to make neccessary changes for 30 games... keeping us in L2 is job done and the only important metric...
2026 Off-Season & Pre-Season Comparison compiled using AI
Rochdale AFC York City (NL Champions) Typical League Two Club Last Game of 2025–26 Season 10 May 2026 (NL Play-Off Final) 25 April 2026 (NL Final Day) 2 May 2026 (L2 Final Day) Return to Training ~3 July 2026 29 June 2026 22–29 June 2026 Total Off-Season Rest. 54 days (7.7 weeks) 65 days (9.3 weeks) 51–58 days (7.3–8.3 weeks) First Competitive Match 1 August 2026 (Carabao Cup Prelim) 3 August 2026 (Carabao Cup Prelim) 8 August 2026 (Carabao Cup R1) Prep Days Until First Match 29 days 35 days 40–47 days Prep Days Until League Opener (15 Aug) 43 days. 47 days. 47–54 days
Key Takeaways
• Rest vs. Preparation: Because Rochdale pushed their return to early July to give players a standard 54-day summer break after Wembley, they absorbed the entire play-off extension out of their pre-season training block rather than their players' holiday.
The biggest squeeze came before the Carabao Cup Preliminary Round against Tranmere Rovers—reporting back around a week later than average while playing a competitive tie a week earlier cut their uninterrupted pre-season training block by nearly two weeks.
Because Henderson said in that podcast last week,that he was happy to help out and frankly it sounded like an invitation to be asked to, he also has the reputation and investment in the club to command respect for his thoughts and intuitions...... Lillis may well be capable of more than being Goalkeeping Coach, I dont know, do you? And Simon is Co-Chairman, and probably knows Henderson better than his Co-Chairman Cameron does... or at least he should do...The Board has to take the initiative, the clock is ticking ... Who knows , they may have already started but the least they can be doing is sounding out the opinions of the senior players... and coaches.....and weighing their options...
Its a difficult situation, , Watson has a 3 year contract, and I presume Magnay probably has too, sacking both would be expensive but not as expensive as another relegation, I presume any compensation could be paid over the lifetimeof their respective contracts if neccessary, Magnay may want to stay but a new manager may not have use for him. But can he take over the reins at least for a while to any useful effect? Equally, surely they didnt employ a rookie manager on a 3 year contract without various performance guarantees? Hope for the best, plan for the worst... ? You then have the expense of a replacement manager ... but what is the alternative? Do we have people in- house capable of taking over? The obvious candidate would be Henderson as player-manager at least whilst a search is conducted. Simon needs to get on the phone tomorrow and start sounding him out...This shambles cannot be allowed to be come a catastrophe.
Nearly 60% of the possesion and only 7 shots at goal....tells you in undeniable statistics that whatever "system" Watson has invented, only works inside his own head..30 players including a few with experience at much higher levels seem unable to unravel what he is trying to coach into them...the worst goals against record , the worst goals for record and 60% of possession....he is like a bus driver that sits in the front and imagines where he is going and never bothers to tell the passengers or even switches the igntion on... Its simply not management, even his pronouncements to supporters are "like, amazin'ly " incomprehensible. God knows how the players are expected to take his manic witterings onboard and then apply them on the pitch ... Time to change before there isnt enough time left to make any difference....
Half time and only 1 shot ( of only 3) on target, not even a corner gained....dismal stuff.. This is not a situation that can be allowed to continue, we are no further forward, in terms of being a League 2 side, now than we were when they sacked Stockdale....
On the basis that Maguire is training (again) and the assumption that Paterson can play a left wing role or drop into a midfield 4 were it neccessary ,this would be my starting 11, the subs would depend on the opposition, and the suspected fragility of Maguire and Beckwith on the same side of the pitch. A selection for an away game at a top 10 club should be different to the selection for a home game against near- table rivals..We are getting to the must win at home and try to nick points away from home situation. We have to assume that players with 100s of games behind them present a safer proposition than young players prone to rookie mistakes. Even then , at a more granular level, Tasker would get my vote where Wilson perhaps doesn't.. horses for courses...utilise the squad ...similarly using Henderson and Hayes later in the game when the opposition is tiring is an obvious move. Going into the next transfer window, there are players who are unlikely to feature and who may want a move away, I think Taylor's contract is up in January so that might create 1 space. The fitness problem Rodney has might be an opportunity to mutually cancell his contract in some way. I would also try to offload Dieseruvwe in exchange for a more, ahem, "ebullient" Centre Forward...equally there are a number of players who might want to look for pastures new and I wouldn't try to stop most of them....
According to Transfermarkt, 18 Rochdale AFC players have contracts listed as expiring on 30 June 2027 (note that loan players such as Nils Ramming, Dajaune Brown, Charlie Tasker, and Kaiden Wilson are listed as expiring 31 May 2027, and Kane Taylor on 2 January 2027). Jenkins, Maguire ,Smith and Francis' contracts run out in June 2028 https://www.transfermarkt.com/
Waller Tasker, Flint, Maguire Beckwith East Gilmour Allen Smith Brown Paterson
Spaven plus 6 more from: TAR Hayes ZSD Middleton Dieseruvwe Henderson EEL Wilson Adeeko Pettit Rodney Francis Hannant Taylor Sherring Bilongo Jenkins( INJURED) Moss ( INJURED) Ramming (INJURED)
If Watson is going, you have to hope his fitness trainers are going with him.... The injury list has meant that we have never seen a full-strength side in action and we probably never will... I guess its the luck of the draw, but as Napoleon said " I would rather have a lucky General than a good one". Maybe Watson is a talented assistant , maybe he will be an excellent manager at some stage in the future, but professional sport is brutal and repeatedly losing games at this level is every likely to have only one outcome.
When we got relegated 4 seasons ago neither the management nor 90% of the squad was good enough despite several getting tranfers to better teams and some developing decent careers after their loan spells here. My worry is that even a lucky manager might not have enough to work with if the decision to change manager doesnt get made quickly enough for impact on probably a dozen, maybe even half of the current squad...
EFL 2 is all about power, pace and physicality you have to have those qualities in your side before you can earn the right to play neat, tidy, stylish, dare I say technical football.....And you need a system and players that have the capability and talent to score 2 goals a game, week in, week out....
This is a signing that shouldn't have needed a second of consideration. When quality like Jamie Allen presents itself , you have to take it with both hands. Our situation demands we put all hands on deck. The opportunity to play alongside a player with Jamie's pedigree is rare at this level, and frankly he will only make our younger players better. He is a player you could build a team around at 31 years old. Paterson and Allen should have enough to run midfield against most in this division.. maybe now the wingers will get better service and even Brown will benefit...
You should study,the work of W Edwards Deming, indeed everyone should .i have no doubt the Ogdens were introduced to Deming's philosophy at Harvard Business School, Its a key component of many courses there.. the pity is that few UK Universities are interested in his methods....
The growth in the fanbase will be incremental. In reality its taken the last 3 seasons in the National League with decent to astonishing results on the pitch to add 1000+ to the gates, . This season we have sold over 1000 youth season tickets. Buying a season ticket is a notable point in a supporters journey. What started as an occasional Saturday afternoon with some mates has become a regurlar event... This means there are now 1000 additional lads ( mainly I guess) who will encourage other mates to come to an occasional game and they in due course will, if the atmosphere and the results on the pitch are good and they enjoy the whole experience,, bring yet more of their pals. Meanwhile other supporters are bringing kids, who in turn will get into the habit.... Its going to take time but the club is slowly extrcating itself from decades of decline and making do. The 5000 attendance target keeps everyone focused on improvement, as I have mentioned here several times before, continuous improvement has to be built into our DNA as a club, attention to detail, everyone suggesting improvements, not letting anything slide or deteriorate. This is howJapan rebuilt after WW2, its the essence of Toyota and Honda and it's how this club will grow and develop, one small step at a time building on previous small steps, taking care, building customer satisfaction, building strong relationships, sharing the vision.....and then on to project 6000...growth in the fanbase leads to stronger teams, more inv3stment, a bigger academy, more community involvement and an even bigger fanbase. The cycle is virtuous
At this stage we need to keep players as fit as possible.... avoiding injuries in games that are meaningless in the wider context would be a smart move...I expect more of the same at Fleetwood.. going into the York game with more players available would be ideal....We have to concentrate on gaining League points.....we have to avoid falling behind the teams around us as a minimum
To be more clear I am saying there will be at least 23 games on other pitches as well as our own which may or not be as good as ours and in weather which in winter will undoubtedly be awful on many occasions in Rochdale and at other venues....
The Accrington match actually showed us that whilst our pitch drains well and hasn't cut up particularly , it does seem become very slick, which is a feature of the type of surface, and will cause problems for wingers and players who have to turn quickly or make a well-weighted pass. Equally a delicate first touch also becomes very difficult... Accrington played direct simple football, often missing out midfield and passing the ball 30% less than we did, whilst concentrating on putting the ball into our penalty area as often as possible... ..26 shots to 5...with 10 - 1 on target. For balance, the stats for the Port Vale game were quite even in just about every measurable area but they capitalised on what from the highlights looks like some very poor defending.