 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 11:43 16 Nov 2026
Name me a player in the history of the game who hasn't done that I noticed those things too, and also that at that point we were under increasing pressure, which meant the availability of team-mates to receive the ball and the more rapid closing down of Allen in particular resulted in a couple of errors At no point did he stop pressing the opposition, or go hiding. There were no negatives to his performance except for those determined to find something |
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 18:03 15 Nov 2026
Thought it worth taking a little time to reflect on his performance yesterday The early impetus we had was largely down to him. Comments around me were "What a difference he makes", and that's unsurprising, given his most recent career experience The most important thing was, he was busting a gut in the Dale cause. Varying position between helping out deep in midfield, to venturing forward and knitting together some good passing movement, he ran his socks off for 60 minutes. It's appreciated He also could be seen pointing things out to his team-mates. I wonder if this had a slightly intimidating effect on Gilmour (the captain) and inhibited his performance In posting at half time that i'd love to see Allen and Hendo have a full 45 minutes together, i wasn't really expecting Allen to last the entire second half given the effort he'd put in. What i really wanted to see was them both on the pitch for a significant period, and i hope (expect) we'll see that in the games ahead It must've been a strange, bittersweet experience for him. As his game time improves, the quality of his passing and ability to spot an opportunity for a throughball (Brown needs to start anticipating them better) we should see the benefit. The free range he was given is something that the manager (whoever it is during his short spell) needs to build the rest of the midfield around [Post edited 15 Nov 18:14]
|
 | Forum Reply | Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? at 17:06 15 Nov 2026
Paterson, Taylor, Smith, not to mention McGuire and due to newness in L2, Pettit (and i'm sure there's others) but we haven't seen anywhere near enough of them at this level for sound judgements to be made They could all turn out to make a difference, and i hope they do |
 | Forum Reply | Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? at 15:55 15 Nov 2026
That's why these debates around rearranging deckchairs on the Titanic are of little value Pointing this out isn't about closing down debate |
 | Forum Reply | Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? at 13:34 15 Nov 2026
Yes, and whilst i wasn't remotely suggesting debates shouldn't happen, or that "the views of fans" aren't valuable (i'd be a hypocrite to suggest that) but i was pointing out how very specific points come to naught in very short order Even so...a midfield of Adeeko and Gilmour with Allen given a free role (as required) would've been the much better option, despite what your interpretation of "structure" might be |
 | Forum Reply | Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? at 09:17 15 Nov 2026
Sorry btb, and even though i engage in them myself, but these tactics debates are useless until we have a more tactically astute manager EDIT: Let me update that, with an example. Pre-match yesterday, 442 and I (and others joined in) posted multiple times on how Jamie Allen might fit into the starting lineup. On being pushed, i suggested ZSD should be the one omitted. We needed a solid base: Allen, Gilmour, Adeeko When the starting line-up was announced, it was obvious there were flaws and that's exactly how it panned out. After a promising start, York gradually took hold of the game with ZSD missing in action (not really his fault) So, what's the point of these debates? As fans, of course we're interested in these things, but yesterday showed just how pointless it was (literally) [Post edited 15 Nov 11:29]
|
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City at 09:10 15 Nov 2026
That last point is key. As things stand, i don't think they're likely to since they're fully committed to the community element of putting something back into the town, which is centred on the football club. You don't pull out of something like that due to temporary setbacks However... the overseeing of the football side has been left in unsafe hands, and Cameron Ogden has a major decision to make on behalf of his family with regard to the joint chairmanship, which has Simon Gauge at the helm. Said this weeks ago, and it's an even bigger issue than IW If SG isn't capable of undoing the mess (using the Ogden's money) CO has to over-ride him, and then provide a more professional input into the footballing operation [Post edited 15 Nov 9:32]
|
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City at 19:43 14 Nov 2026
That's pretty fair, and more or less what i saw Accepting that IW is learning (slowly) on the job, and that the board have decided to back him (for now) we put in a shift today after being turned over by Accy I also thought we looked stronger once we reorganised at the back, with Bilongo alongside Wilson - okay, it was also to allow Flint to try his luck upfield, but it's a combo i'd like to see used again Our main weakness is deep midfield, which exposes our back line. Gilmour unfortunately just isn't up to it. I'd like to think Pettit could make that role his own but it remains an unknown. Put Allen and East in there and we'd have more solidity and more enterprise. Of course, Allen is temporary, so probably Paterson instead, assuming he can live up to his career record We get the ball out to the wings well enough: in terms of structure, that's as old as the hills (Hill's initial flourish too) but we've also got to improve on Brown and Mani in the January window We were up against a better side than us today, but ended up being unlucky not to get something from the game As for the U-block (in other comments), they're kids, and easily outsung by the opposition when things aren't going our way [Post edited 14 Nov 19:48]
|
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City at 17:32 14 Nov 2026
Agree, a point today wouldn't have been a travesty, with several very close calls I think people have short memories. Today, i thought we were closer to York, who remain a very strong side, than when we played them at the back end of last season. In terms of chances created certainly; unfortunately, we've no real bite and insist on shooting ourselves in the foot at the back Gilmour was ghosted for their goal. IW needs to be brave and rest him. East looked far more effective and i'd like to see him starting with Allen. There's a lot of nonsense being spouted about "structure" when what matters is a positive contribution from midfield, where we've been lacking all season Not too downhearted, and we knew the run in to the New Year was going to be tough |
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 13:35 14 Nov 2026
I think you missed the irony... |
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 13:18 14 Nov 2026
Almost certainly in a holding position, maximising his chances of influencing the game from the start |
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 13:16 14 Nov 2026
Who hasn't understood them? |
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 12:47 14 Nov 2026
No. If the nature of the balance of play changes, it would be insane to not have a degree of flexibility to cope with that (i think even you'd be annoyed if we didn't) Jamie Allen is in a very good place to see that for himself with his experience, and make adjustments accordingly |
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 12:45 14 Nov 2026
Who's said it's unfair, when as far as i can see, everyone would agree with that? The Jamie Allen signing has brought it into even sharper focus, but i honestly can't recall anyone claiming our squad wasn't too big |
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 12:07 14 Nov 2026
Understand the concerns, but i'd hazard a guess that we've not suddenly decided to sign him. More likely, Jamie Allen has been biding his time in the hope a club higher up the food chain would make him an offer, but now we're approaching the transfer window, he's agreed to the short term contract Would anyone of us have been happy if he'd now made himself available and we'd said "Sorry Jamie, our squad's too big now" ? [Post edited 14 Nov 12:08]
|
 | Forum Reply | Jamie Allen at 11:55 14 Nov 2026
I'm not particularly fussed about Allen having a designated role It could be that IW will give him free rein to take up whatever role he sees fit as the game develops. The other chosen midfielders will be able to adapt around that So at times we could see him sitting in front of the back four (especially if we find ourselves under the cosh) and at others, in a more advanced position. It wouldn't make much sense to waste his potential influence by having him "fill a slot" in someone's preferred formation |
Please log in to use all the site's facilities |  | D_Alien
|
Site Scores| Prediction League: | 0 | | TOTAL: | 0 |
|