 | Forum Reply | Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? at 08:53 15 Nov 2026
I’m revisiting this thread because it’s 3 months on and the same question is as relevant now as it was then. With 30 odd players, I have zero clue what our best team is. More importantly, how you utilise them. Kane Taylor at left back and Silcott in the centre or number 10 certainly isn’t that. Watson aside, I need a sensible debate based on what we know now. And what as fans would do to / believe would turn our fortunates? What is abundantly evident to me is we need more support around Brown. And more support in front of the back line. Do you sacrifice wingers to accommodate this? [Post edited 15 Nov 8:55]
|
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City at 22:57 14 Nov 2026
Well put. I think the squad size and the nature of the signings is enough to show us he is out of his depth. Somebody else has said it… and we’ve all took the piss out of him but it’s full on Robbie Savage. Rather than work on what you’ve got, adapt and refine and play to the strengths (and weaknesses) it’s like he’s just hoping that the signings will just come good and one day they will just click. Evidently, we have some reasonably talented players. But, it’s just nothing more than that. Individuals. Yes injuries have played their part that’s hard to deny. But it should be a case of slotting somebody into an already refined system (Callum Perry) and they only need to find their own way, the rest is taken care of. For us, it’s like a player steps onto the pitch and is flying solo. Doing what they can and what they think they should be doing but without actually knowing what they should be doing and what others are doing. We’ve heard absolutely nothing from his assistant since his introduction interview. Why? It would be good to hear from him and see if we can take anything different or any positives. At the moment, as you alluded to. He spouts nothing but waffle and he is clinging on and knows it. Even the ‘nice man’ bit is boring now. You can be as nice as you like but you are paid to win football matches not be our friend. Lots of talk of Maynard. Interesting his stats at Notts County weren’t too impressive. But I think the team just needs a robust structure and starting with being hard to beat. Because at the moment, if you have a half decent striker it’s absolutely nailed on he will get 3 to 4 chances against us. It’s like a turkey shoot at times. |
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City at 22:18 14 Nov 2026
Just out of interest I would like to know who you believe is League One quality in this squad? I agree with regards to tactics. We are making a simple game look hard for us and easy for others. The still image above in the thread typifies our season. That gap between the back 4 and the midfield will be the only thing I remember from the Ian Watson reign when we are put out of our misery. [Post edited 14 Nov 22:20]
|
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City at 18:56 14 Nov 2026
Your optimism is admirable. My friend came with me today who is a Lancaster City fan. He said ‘do they play like this every week? They look devoid of leadership and courage. And every pass if not under or overhit is safe and 9 times out of 10 out wide. Nothing through the middle and I know what’s going to happen next’. Sadly, my response was… this is one of the better performances. Yet the games passed by, I said ‘oooooo twice’ at the goal line clearances. The rest was dreadful and the catch up about our careers, family, holidays etc was the only positive I walked away with. He also said Brad Kelly is better than Waller. |
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City at 17:53 14 Nov 2026
His team selections are baffling, his in game management doesn’t exist, his substitutions have zero courage. How has Silcott earned a start? How has Taylor got back in the squad and then started at left back after his last roasting out there? It’s just completely disjointed on and off the pitch. Cameron Ogden was there today and hopefully he looks at the scoreboard and the league table which our manager doesn’t (his words not mine). We are are a third of the way through the season and not a single sign of improvement. Anyone who thinks differently is as deluded. And all the talk of players returning is actually going to cause more harm because the man has zero clue what he wants, what his preferred team is and what people’s natural position is. Not a single player he has signed has shown they are better than what we had last season. I stick by that statement. I thought these times were over for us and the future was bright but I’m absolutely fed up of going again. It’s a chore. And the atmosphere today, even from the U Block was just rock bottom too. The harsh reality of what is unfolding in front of our eyes has hit people like a train. It’s going to be a long winter. The board made an error. For all the good they have done, it’s on them to fix it. 4 wins from 15 in the league with our largest playing budget and squad ever…. They have wasted their money and they are wasting our time. |
 | Forum Reply | Rochdale must act on Ian Watson either way at 09:13 5 Nov 2026
If he was going he would be gone by now. Zero Dale fans have got FA Cup fever and I’ll be surprised if it’s any more than 400 who travel. York will come and give us a pasting in front of a full away end and we move into the bottom 2. The board react, we then lose our following four matches while we find a replacement, new man comes in and we celebrate our first point circa 6 weeks from now at home to Bristol Rovers. Up the Dale. [Post edited 5 Nov 11:52]
|
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Rochdale v Doncaster Rovers (EFL Trophy) at 20:09 3 Nov 2026
Beckwith is Mancini rev 2. Got the ability but his body will forever hold him back. Absolutely cannot blame Watson. He’s a fully grown man going out for a game of football - the fact his body has failed him is the only take away. Some people are just built differently. Hendos genetics are obviously just superior. |
 | Forum Reply | Hendo at 20:28 2 Nov 2026
Alternative view. If Henderson had’ve been utilised properly by Watson then he would’ve broken his reckon a month ago. He even said himself (similar with Moss) he underestimated how good Hendo is and that he hasn’t used him enough. And the proceeded to not use him enough. Another alternative view. Some would argue it’s a professional game, and a fair view on these appearances have been registered in this competition in the first place. So why is this game less important? You’ll never win. But my view is, I hope he gets a cold this evening and isn’t too well tomorrow. [Post edited 2 Nov 20:29]
|
 | Forum Reply | Rochdale must act on Ian Watson either way at 11:31 2 Nov 2026
A good read and a very fair assessment. I got to the end and concluded I don’t believe they have the courage to make the move and replace him. They will argue September is what we are capable of (points over performance of course). The fans argue August and October is what we actually are (points reflect that view). I could understand if we have had to backfill injury’s with youth players. But we have done the opposite. He’s been backed beyond any manager I can ever recall in my time? In preseason I was of the opinion that 5 marquee signings was enough to move us forwards. 17 signings later and I am yet to see any of them really excel (those that have played). The gaps between the lines and the amount of shots the opposition are allowed to take from the edge of our box is frightening. It’s disjointed from front to back. And that’s not personnel. It’s the set up first and foremost. His selections are contributing factors. One thing I would like to point out is South Shields are top of NLN as we discuss this. So was he actually good at his job? Or is that team just good for that level? Mike Williamson has hardly pulled up trees anywhere he’s been since the Gateshead years. And yet he’s now got them top of the league after Watsons departure? Ironically, probably very little change in personnel and system. Familiarity for the squad that remained while the management transition happened. One would say maybe we needed the same? I’ve zoned out of Ian Watson now. Struggle to listen to his interviews because it’s clouded by the same deflection and tone. He’s punching way above his level, learning on the job and no doubt a top coach and evidently a nice man. But it’s not what we needed at this stage of our journey. Who would take us on now? The three names mentioned will probably be thinking if I sit this out another month… a better opportunity will arise. We have a huge squad, half of it on the treatment table, a third of it nowhere near the standard expected. I see no option other than radical changes in January too with atleast 5 departures. Sherring, Wilson, Adeeko, Waller, Ramming, Rodney, Francis, TAR, Kane Taylor and Silcott-D could all leave tomorrow for me. There is better players at this level than those, and I’m being generous to some of the others. But we are weaker than this time last year and that is absolutely criminal given the money he’s had. [Post edited 2 Nov 11:35]
|
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Port Vale v Rochdale at 14:41 31 Oct 2026
People need to stop blaming injuries. The man has brought 17 players through the door. Only one today from the ‘originals’ of last season started. It’s his team and it’s his mess. Injuries a factor but why are these players here if they aren’t good enough? That is the only reason he hasn’t blamed injuries because he knows he’s thrown our budget down the drain. The board are just as culpable. They have selected him and then backed him. Both as inexperienced as each other and it’s bleak viewing. |
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Accrington Stanley at 23:07 24 Oct 2026
Keeping them all happy is borderline impossible so some leaving has to happen when the time Is right. Separately, the amount of squabbling, arms in the air and general poor body language and blame culture today and at other points throughout the season is hard to stomach. It’s a culture we didn’t really see under Jim. Or rarely anyway. Watson needs to get a grip of that fast. |
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Accrington Stanley at 22:37 24 Oct 2026
Watching Accy was what I thought we’d ordered from South Shields. He’s had circa 16 competitive games in change now if you include the America cup. In addition to that 6/7 friendlies. I still sit here now wondering when we will control a game for 90 minutes and look polished. Injuries have played a part, no denying that. But whatever the 11 I’m not sure we have a full turn key plan for a game. He’s learning on the job which is acceptable but it’s not what was promised. Far from it. And he has probably been backed more than any other manager in this football clubs history. |
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Accrington Stanley at 22:25 24 Oct 2026
I agree. It’s why it’s difficult to defend Watson because he has made some silly decisions on one hand and then a distinct lack of the decisions on the other. He admitted he was wrong on Moss not playing and same again the other night with Hendo. What he see’s in Sherring who is clearly not an MRKT signing along with a few of the others is beyond me. Everyone played poorly today. Including the staff. I just don’t like the vibe from dugout. Something doesn’t seem right for me. Josh Lillis is the most vocal and active (and rightly so at the minute) but the body language and lack of activity and animation from the rest of them is odd. Beckwith has to start on Saturday. We need people in their natural positions. Not a RB playing left back and a centre half playing RB. Tasker has done well in rece recent weeks but we have landed back at the must get a clean sheet stage. So we must play our strongest team available and today wasn’t it. Francis, Sherring, Waller, Wilson, Adeeko all don’t get in our 11 last season. Telling sign on where we are. It’s a squad of 30 with 10 who shouldn’t be here. |
 | Forum Reply | Fan services email at 17:32 21 Oct 2026
The wire with the small LEDs on it from within one of the glow sticks was thrown on the pitch as a Grimsby player was lining up to take a corner. You can’t take the bottle top off a bottle off a bottle of water but then hand out items like that to teenagers. I mean they are made from foam and weigh the same as a bottle top no doubt so Dale 4 Life is a little bit OTT but makes a point. I certainly don’t see death by guillotine off one of those. More just annoying and felt a bit like I was at a Disney on Ice show at the AO Arena. But, trial and error on the fan experience. On the main the kids loved them… who they were intended for of course. |
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Grimsby Town at 23:01 20 Oct 2026
Yeh your second point is valid. No one team has really played us off the park and looked silky. Grimsby were good tonight but I felt most threatened by crosses and corners than being carved open in open play. You could argue it was self inflicted pain as both goals came down the left hand side and after a series of silly decisions, chances to clear and hesitation. It’s certainly there to go at in this league but our injuries are the primary burden. Until the new year I am points over performance. With a view of a few tweaks in Jan. The only real target this season is staying in this league and everyone top down bottom up growing on the back of the experience. I am sure Watson has seen enough now to know where the extra attention is needed. Collecting points will allow him to work on that without any distractions. |
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Grimsby Town at 22:32 20 Oct 2026
After promotion I said to my Dad that this season I just wanted to turn up, no pressure going into a game and just go out and enjoy ourselves while never in danger and not really threatening the top. Last season was pretty stressful being scared go drop points, turned out beautiful but I aged 5 years. That game tonight was a far cry from the national league. It’s was fast, frantic and evidently better quality than the league below. Every team that’s been to here have been energetic and ‘up for it’. Shrewsbury was a flattering scoreline - but they weren’t abysmal nor were we great. It’s nice to be back. Tonight was fun. I think a draw flattered us after a poor second half but we take it, we learn from it and we move on. It’s clear the central midfield is the area in question. Not fully convinced on Adeeko, Gilmour has now found some sharpness and looking far more assured but you can tell he has hit his ceiling and it’s likely we won’t get much more out of him, Francis for me just isn’t what we need and yet to actually see him control a game. Petit has more presence and seems to be more involved but again, big step up and never really got a chance last season so a big ask for him when he finally returns. The immediate craving for me is to see us control a game for 90 minutes. We are seeing glimpses of what the plan is, but we drift in and out of it. 4 points from tonight and the approaching Accy game would be lovely. Let’s see if we can roll back the years and do a job on them like we used to. As other have said. Tasker was brilliant and my MOM. Ian’s in game management still leaves me a little bit bemused. Generally does what my brain is thinking but after a goal rather than to prevent a goal. Sub no.2 being the example. [Post edited 20 Oct 22:38]
|
 | Forum Reply | TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Swindon Town at 20:09 3 Oct 2026
Got the job done. Wasn’t great and a very stop start game. Swindon chipping away at us and came for a smash and grab. At 60 minutes it was looking like they would do exactly that. And then the Brown miss made me think it was our turn to suffer after lauding it up against Fondop/Oldham. But… they dug deep. Kept going and the substitutions were the obvious thing to do and it paid off. Cian Hayes is a menace. Not everything he does comes off but he has the heart of a lion and I love watching him. Credit to all the young lads too. Wilson, Tasker and Ramming all solid enough. Sherring’s distribution was ropey at times but his positional play was miles better. Flint is flint and we need to offer him a deal now before somebody like Salford come steaming in to weaken us. Still lots to improve on but results allow you the time to do that. I enjoyed Watsons post match interview too. He witnessed the same game as us so that’s refreshing. The players are playing with some passion, the fans are turning up, the away end actually has some fans in it week in week out and it just feels good to be back and respected for being Rochdale and hopefully a tough place to come. One game at a time but just keep putting some points on the board and enjoy the ride. Pitch is class too. Credit to the contractors, groundsman and the club for the investment. It’s took a hammering with Rugby our games and the ladies and it’s flawless. |
 | Forum Reply | Conference 26/27 at 07:26 28 Sep 2026
I can’t help but think we would’ve ended up down there for atleast two or three more seasons. Jim would’ve gone regardless, and I am sure we would’ve retained a few more Players than we let go. But with a new manager, and probably still Ian Watson, it would’ve been a very tall order to recover from the heartbreak and then rebuild. We are blessed to be here where we are today and the recent upturn in results helps you reflect with a bit more of a stable mind. Crazy times, probably once’s in a generation stuff. |
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Walsall v Rochdale at 19:10 12 Sep 2026
I agree. But these prem clubs put clauses in the loans I’m sure. A backline of Moss, Flint, Maguire and Beckwith and Waller sat behind them in goal and my fingernails would be relieved. The young loanee lads have been thrown to the Lions because of the situation. BUT, he told us he doesn’t do squad depth signings so we have every reason to be expecting them to perform. Both our strikers need a goal urgently. I think if Brown grabs one he will get stronger. Mani, I just don’t think he is what we need right now, he isn’t intelligent enough for this level. They worked hard today but it wasn’t pretty. But 3 points against Oldham and it’s a solid week. I just can’t see it. They seem to know how to do us every time. |
Please log in to use all the site's facilities |  | beat_the_bishop
|
Site Scores| Prediction League: | 0 | | TOTAL: | 0 |
|