Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v York City
at 18:31 14 Nov 2026

OK this is a minority view.

Accepting IW has lost our identity, starting Taylor at LB was weird, we're still one of the favourites to go down, Tasker and Paterson are yet more unexplained absences, I thought this was our best performance to date. Unlike other games we didn't fold after conceding, we weren't 3 down in 20 mins ....against one of the top sides (by table position). There seemed to be something of a pattern to our play, gaps between players seemed less to me and we were in the game for most of the 90 mins. Above all we had 5 shots on target (2 cleared off the line) to York's 3 so we did have a cutting edge. Had either of Brown's headers or Middleton's chip gone in - different game!

Allen set the tone pressing high and delivering some fast incisive passing like the Brown cross 442 mentioned, TAR has his best league game for us - never stopped working, defended high crosses well and contributed to the last 10 mins dominance (that was when York sat back rather than Hayes being a wizard - for every time he beats his FB he loses the ball twice over and he's so lightweight defensively. Hannant does both and his chip for Brown was perfect, sadly the finish wasn't. Thought Wilson was less vulnerable to risky forays than some games and his driving runs had an effect (as did Bilongo's later). Flint was solid in the air though because of his lack of pace he sets up so deep those gaps to MF others mention get bigger.

Gilmour made a mistake for their goal but otherwise won many tackles and covered Allen. ZSD seemed to have a roving role to cover runs which did work defensively but prevented him being as effective in an attacking role. Middleton tried hard offensively and defensively but struggled to make many incisive runs because of good covering. Brown got little applause when he was subbed which I thought was unfair - he worked tirelessly, won loads more headers than Mani and nearly scored 2.

So I'm still highly critical of IW's decisions since arriving on recruitment and formation but I thought there was a little progress today. Sadly support is fickle so this is also a plea to find some positives!

I await the opprobrium.
Forum
Reply
Jamie Allen
at 16:55 13 Nov 2026

You are of course right 442 about IW's recruitment failures but I went to the Open Training day in the Summer and spent 45 minutes watching Allen stroke passes all over the pitch, with the foresight and ease of the quality player he is. Let's hope his contribution helps build the sort of success which mean East, Gilmour and Petit want to stay.
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Port Vale v Rochdale
at 11:04 9 Nov 2026

Interesting quote from IW's interview post Fleetwood on the BBC Football Results page:-"we've got a big group now, much bigger than what I wanted and what's required to have a tight-knit unit"
Forum
Reply
Magic Mick
at 09:45 9 Nov 2026

I thought the Board's lack of footballing knowledge to recruit effectively was the problem?
Forum
Reply
Rochdale must act on Ian Watson either way
at 20:07 6 Nov 2026

Quite possibly but seems a strange leadership where the players have to front up for the manager?
Forum
Reply
Rochdale must act on Ian Watson either way
at 18:07 6 Nov 2026

Seems Harvey Gilmour's been left with facing the questions before Fleetwood - looks and sounds totally disheartened.
Forum
Reply
Rochdale must act on Ian Watson either way
at 11:48 2 Nov 2026

Absolutely. I guess most fans would agree with the analysis of the problems but not necessarily the praise of the McNulty-type solution (which I share) - "Not only did his sides aim to control games by controlling those distances, but he also understood that before you can build a successful team, you have to build a collective".

Many of those whose recent loss of faith you cite are the same fans who couldn't wait to replace 'boring' McNulty with exciting Klopp-style Ian Watson. Watson came in and dismantled the formation and personnel which was the very basis of that success.

Grass greener, what you wish for etc!
[Post edited 2 Nov 11:52]
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Port Vale v Rochdale
at 15:09 31 Oct 2026

I thought Brown did well considering the lack of service and he made our 2nd goal - sadly Mani has been a lost soul this season so he's not the solution
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Port Vale v Rochdale
at 14:57 31 Oct 2026

Accepting that Vale might have eased off 2nd half we did win it 2-1 so I agree with our players the formation seems to offer more control (under any manager)
Maybe look to stay in the game for the first hour and potentially then tweak the formation and bring on wingers?

Having seen 442s post - of course IW's recruitment choices don't help this formation change (or anything else it seems) but perhaps this suggestion makes the best of them - at least with the currently available players
[Post edited 31 Oct 15:02]
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Port Vale v Rochdale
at 13:29 31 Oct 2026

Perhaps set up with a formation, personnel and tactic to control the game more - aim not to lose as a start? Earn the right to play and rebuild confidence.
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Accrington Stanley
at 13:30 25 Oct 2026

or equally .... last season we were winning matches because of the good culture
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Accrington Stanley
at 10:45 25 Oct 2026

we've got a 23rd place GD too
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Accrington Stanley
at 10:40 25 Oct 2026

Yes, as others have said, the lack of energy, decisiveness or any plan B from the dugout is the most worrying long term. Accy's formation stopped our wingers effecting the game, put pressure on our 'vulnerable' FBs and bypassed our M/F from minute 1. We decided to match their formation in the 70th minute at 0-5 down.
Forum
Reply
Fan services email
at 16:44 21 Oct 2026

I saw the notice on the 'big' screen but missed the incident(s?) D4L - can you expand
[Post edited 21 Oct 17:00]
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Grimsby Town
at 22:05 20 Oct 2026

Partly down to TAR (another injury?) being replaced by Taylor at LB which he isn't and it meant moving Tasker to his less effective side - should have been Beckwith @ LB from HT.

Frenetic first half although Grimsby looked strongest to me and we were dead and buried @ 1-2 until Hendo's (& Hannant's) cameos.

As others have said we lost out in midfield even with 3 which needs solving & I don't see Petit as the solution. Agree though It is the way we play so we're in for a rollercoaster season and with the table so congested safety is a long way away.
[Post edited 20 Oct 22:08]
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Huddersfield Town v Rochdale (EFL Trophy)
at 19:22 6 Oct 2026

Very possibly, along with the rest of the promotion winning squad if IW gets his way?
Forum
Reply
Refwatch - Huddersfield Town v Rochdale (EFL Trophy)
at 18:56 6 Oct 2026

No Rodney - disappointing, is he injured again?
Forum
Reply
Attendance Saturday
at 12:59 4 Oct 2026

With you on the optimism & Project 5000 but I was frisked for first time for 3 games - consistency!!
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Swindon Town
at 10:48 4 Oct 2026

Agree about Tasker (class) & Wilson (if he gets his head up for the pass after the driving run) but Sherring lost half a dozen headers which is worrying for a CB. But yes, whilst EFL2 is more physical than NL, the technical side is surprisingly ordinary ... so far!
Forum
Reply
TVOS Preview - Rochdale v Swindon Town
at 18:45 2 Oct 2026

Don't agree, as you'd expect DA - McNulty took over a disaster so had to change for success; Watson took over the most successful Dale team ever...

if it ain't broke....
Please log in to use all the site's facilities

tony_roch975


Site Scores

Prediction League: 0
TOTAL: 0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026