 | Forum Reply | Russell Brand is guilty at 18:57 14 Nov 2026
‘ Does anyone seriously believe that either of them would be in prison / under investigation by now, if victims had gone to the police rather than the press?’ That’s an incredible thing to say. Do you seriously believe that if someone made an allegation of sexual assault against a high profile celebrity that it wouldn’t be investigated properly and a report sent to the CPS? I guess ultimately it boils down to what kind of society you want to live in. One where allegations of sexual misconduct are played out on the front page of a media organisation with that organisation acting as judge and jury. Or one where those allegations are examined, scrutinized and if appropriate sent before a proper Judge and jury with all the legal safeguards in place to ensure the right result is achieved. I know which one I’d choose every time. |
 | Forum Reply | Russell Brand is guilty at 15:48 14 Nov 2026
Journalists should not get a free run at it though. They’ve abused their positions in the past with the phone hacking scandal, the fake Sheikh, entrapment of young stars for newspaper headlines and, as I’ve mentioned several times on this thread, the reporting of cases around Operation Midland and other high profile investigations that turned out to be complete nonsense. Peoples livelihoods and reputations forever damaged as a result. Some people died before being exonerated. Your post also highlights an inherent risk for journalism; the need for a story to increase circulation. As you say, it’s a money making enterprise and you’ll pay for a good story which may affect the honesty or credibility of an informant or the honesty or integrity of a journalist for that matter. As with all things in life, their is a balance to be struck. My point, throughout this thread, has been that matters of this type should sit with the Police, not journalists and the media. That way you wouldn’t be in any danger of being sued for libel. Win, win. [Post edited 14 Nov 15:56]
|
 | Forum Reply | How Pierce Charles transformed the way QPR play – Analysis at 15:36 14 Nov 2026
I did speculate earlier this season as to whether Callum Ward and Salomon had changed their training to, in effect, mimic Charles’ exact style of play should he move on in January or get injured. I think this is almost certain to be the case. I wonder what Ward and Salomen’s thoughts on this would be and whether they consider themselves better keepers as a result. An interview with either of the backups to Charles or the head of goalkeeper training would be interesting to listen to the impact of having an almost revolutionary goalkeeper in our midst. [Post edited 14 Nov 15:38]
|
 | Forum Reply | Russell Brand is guilty at 17:25 12 Nov 2026
I agree, there are areas where it is perfectly valid for investigative journalists to do incredibly important work. Corruption and cover ups need the brightest of lights shone on them and all power to them. This however is a completely different set of circumstances dealing with matters that sit firmly and rightly with the Police to investigate fully, impartially, without publicity and where no money passes hands between journalist and anyone willing to tell their story rather than the Police ( CICA payments aside). |
 | Forum Reply | Russell Brand is guilty at 14:09 12 Nov 2026
Well call me old fashioned but I think allegations of criminality should be examined and adjudicated on in a Court room after full disclosure of the facts, not on the front page of the Sun or Guardian (There’s a another question around payments to people for their stories). Their job is to sell papers and there is no obligation to present the full facts in a way that may be slightly less sensational. To me, unless someone is convicted in a Court then it’s little more than tittle tattle which invariably leads to an unseemly torches and pitchforks scenario. It’s the modern equivalent of ghouls going to watch a public execution for the fun of it. [Post edited 12 Nov 14:15]
|
 | Forum Reply | Russell Brand is guilty at 17:14 11 Nov 2026
I’m sad to say I’ve never done jury service. Would love to do it. |
 | Forum Reply | Russell Brand is guilty at 16:12 11 Nov 2026
You’re right, it never got near a trial but everyone knows all about it. How is that the case?? You’ve rather missed the point of my post which wasn’t about false allegations but the role of the media in cases like these. The only reason you know about Operation Midland is because the press were all over the case for months and months. What if that case had gone to trial? How is any defendant going to get a fair trial after it’s been splashed all over the front page repeatedly. I personally don’t think it’s the medias job to search for or convince people to make criminal allegations. I also don’t think it’s the media’s job to, for example, have a helicopter filming the Police searching the house of a high profile celebrity who was never charged and subsequently found to have done nothing wrong. The role of the Police in that particular instance was also a disgrace. The point I’m making is that the media are often not campaigning angels determined to see Justice done. The phone tapping scandal another example of how low they’ll sink. |
 | Forum Reply | Russell Brand is guilty at 10:55 11 Nov 2026
The press widely reported on the allegations made by Carl Beech of a pedophile ring involving the political, military and religious elite in this country. That turned out to be a complete fantasy which destroyed innocent people’s lives (not those in charge of the appalling investigation of course). The press aren’t always a force for good with regards to historic sexual assaults. There’s a serious risk of a bandwagon leading to a firm assumption that people are guilty. I’ve no doubt that with all the media exposure of Brand and now Walliams other people will be queuing up to come forward. Any future jury will also be very prejudiced, despite, I’m sure warnings by the trial judge, due to their knowledge of previous offending/convictions. This would normally be kept from jurors. There is a significant risk of cases like this gathering so much momentum that any question of a critical, scrupulous examination of the evidence goes out the window. |
 | Forum Reply | Loan Players - Update at 21:26 10 Nov 2026
Just watched the last 40 minutes of Bradford v York. Kieran Morgan ran the show. A very good performance. Got an assist and created two other good chances. He’s played the last two games (against lesser teams) for Bradford and they’ve won 7-0 and 4-0. |
 | Forum Reply | Glorious Glen dispels Rangers’ possession plight – Report at 19:43 9 Nov 2026
I have slated Varane relentlessly on here pretty much since he signed and he did make a couple of stupid errors that did, and could, have cost us goals but his all round play is hugely improved from where it was. Mind you, training multiple times a week for two years should do that. Poku continues to disappoint. Dembele was far more effective in the short time he was on. |
 | Forum Reply | Loan Players - Update at 10:59 8 Nov 2026
He seems very unpopular with the fanbase…but then again that is the fanbase on X so maybe not entirely representative. |
 | Forum Reply | Match Thread: will QPR show NEW METTLE or will LINCOLN PARK the bus? at 18:10 7 Nov 2026
I’d like to see JS show a bit more faith in Alemeyhu. I know Varane is better without the ball and can, at times, use his physicality and height to disrupt and intercept but IA has shown how good he can be on the ball. I think IA and Kamara may be quite similar in style and I’m not saying he should play 90 minutes but, circumstances depending, he needs to be exposed to the Championship a bit more. Game model and all that. [Post edited 7 Nov 18:13]
|
 | Forum Reply | Match Thread: will QPR show NEW METTLE or will LINCOLN PARK the bus? at 16:17 7 Nov 2026
I did say a few games ago that we have hugely improved our squad from where it was two or three years ago. That should enable us to comfortably tread water in mid table. Any idea that this squad is good enough for the top 6 or even the top 8 is for the birds. |
 | Forum Reply | Loan Players - Update at 15:16 7 Nov 2026
Kieran Morgan starts for Bradford and Jaylen Pearman makes the match day squad st last for Swindon ( who are 2 nil down after 12 minutes. Taxi for Holloway. |
Please log in to use all the site's facilities |  | Beckenhamhoop
|
Site Scores| Prediction League: | 7 | | TOTAL: | 7 |
|