Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Welsh NHS 13:04 - Nov 2 with 6354 viewsReslovenSwan1

I have found the NHS to be very good in my experience but it is coming under a lot of criticism and so is the Senedd. Tha people can complain but if they want better services they will have to pay more.

We have in global terms a cheap service. The cost of private health show you how expensive these provisions are . Pay more get a better service

We in Wales can get better funding with a swipe of a pen. We gave fallen behind England and need to catch up . Around £624m would be saved by abolishing FREE PRESCRIPTION CHARGES.. Want the same service? Then get in with it. We are a democracy. It is about £20 a citizen. Older people in properties with £250k plus fully paid off are pleading poverty.
[Post edited 2 Nov 13:07]

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

-5
Welsh NHS on 15:35 - Nov 10onehunglow

Welsh NHS on 15:28 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

11 % in England do pay prescription charges and this goes back on to the sysm. 11% uplift compared to Wales. This is a huge figure. About £70min Wales. £1.4 billion in England

From what I read everyone over 60 in England gets free prescriptions..It is madness . These are among the richest people on the planet.
Effectively many millionaires getting free drugs . It's nuts.

I stick to the topic and do not debate whether you are a dimwit or not. Some people on here might be vulnerable..

I do know one thing. You can only debate properly if I agree with you. The NHS is sacred and emotive and is actually based in international standard very cheap.

Too cheap..
.


Now the English amongst the richest on the planet !
My God
Incredible
Poor Wales eh

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

2
Welsh NHS on 16:24 - Nov 10ReslovenSwan1

Welsh NHS on 15:35 - Nov 10 by onehunglow

Now the English amongst the richest on the planet !
My God
Incredible
Poor Wales eh


Around 79% of pensioner households (aged 65 and over) in England own their own home, according to one housing survey.

74% own property out right. ( No mortgage) .This will be at an average of around £300,000 much higher in the south obviously .

100 % of the get their prescription drugs off the NHS bill. Many English pensioners downsized and came to Wales using Welsh service and drugs paid for by the Senedd Rural hospitals in mid Wales are not efficient to say in Surrey.

NHS in crisis. I wonder why. Solve it a a stoke of a pen. Abolish fre prescriptions except in exceptional case. £623m saved in Wales £12 billon extra in England.

Wales is not CUBA.
[Post edited 10 Nov 21:14]

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

-1
Welsh NHS on 18:12 - Nov 10Whiterockin

Welsh NHS on 16:24 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

Around 79% of pensioner households (aged 65 and over) in England own their own home, according to one housing survey.

74% own property out right. ( No mortgage) .This will be at an average of around £300,000 much higher in the south obviously .

100 % of the get their prescription drugs off the NHS bill. Many English pensioners downsized and came to Wales using Welsh service and drugs paid for by the Senedd Rural hospitals in mid Wales are not efficient to say in Surrey.

NHS in crisis. I wonder why. Solve it a a stoke of a pen. Abolish fre prescriptions except in exceptional case. £623m saved in Wales £12 billon extra in England.

Wales is not CUBA.
[Post edited 10 Nov 21:14]


Selective reasoning on your part. You do realise that the percentage of pensioner households who own their own home in Wales is 87%. So by your reckoning Welsh people are better off than English. Next question clueless.
2
Welsh NHS on 19:03 - Nov 10SullutaCreturned

Welsh NHS on 15:28 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

11 % in England do pay prescription charges and this goes back on to the sysm. 11% uplift compared to Wales. This is a huge figure. About £70min Wales. £1.4 billion in England

From what I read everyone over 60 in England gets free prescriptions..It is madness . These are among the richest people on the planet.
Effectively many millionaires getting free drugs . It's nuts.

I stick to the topic and do not debate whether you are a dimwit or not. Some people on here might be vulnerable..

I do know one thing. You can only debate properly if I agree with you. The NHS is sacred and emotive and is actually based in international standard very cheap.

Too cheap..
.


Oh AGAIN, the money spent on prescriptions saves the NHS money, it's been said several times but you ignore it, that is not debate, it's ignorance.

You need opposing opinions for a debate, you people willing to accept when they are proved wrong.

Like I said previously, there are things that should never be given on scripts and they would save money, anything that can be bought in a shop (like paracetamol) should never be put on a script.

However, you refuse to change your position, you drone on and on saying the same things over and over again, that is NOT debate, that is lecturing. You don't accept that other people may be right, you cannot adjust your position in the face of evidence.
3
Welsh NHS on 20:32 - Nov 10union_jack

Welsh NHS on 19:03 - Nov 10 by SullutaCreturned

Oh AGAIN, the money spent on prescriptions saves the NHS money, it's been said several times but you ignore it, that is not debate, it's ignorance.

You need opposing opinions for a debate, you people willing to accept when they are proved wrong.

Like I said previously, there are things that should never be given on scripts and they would save money, anything that can be bought in a shop (like paracetamol) should never be put on a script.

However, you refuse to change your position, you drone on and on saying the same things over and over again, that is NOT debate, that is lecturing. You don't accept that other people may be right, you cannot adjust your position in the face of evidence.


Just wait until he manages to squeeze the Supporters’ Trust into the ‘debate’.😂

Are Sperm Whales the reason the sea is so salty?
Poll: Bony - Would You Want Him Back?

3
Welsh NHS on 20:37 - Nov 10Whiterockin

Welsh NHS on 20:32 - Nov 10 by union_jack

Just wait until he manages to squeeze the Supporters’ Trust into the ‘debate’.😂


Im surprised we haven't had the Turkish health insurance system mentioned.
0
Welsh NHS on 21:17 - Nov 10ReslovenSwan1

Welsh NHS on 20:37 - Nov 10 by Whiterockin

Im surprised we haven't had the Turkish health insurance system mentioned.


I had a Turkish neighbour for a while. He told me Turkish health service was way better than the NHS.

Shoot the messenger. It's easier.

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

-1
Welsh NHS (n/t) on 21:20 - Nov 10max936

Welsh NHS on 21:17 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

I had a Turkish neighbour for a while. He told me Turkish health service was way better than the NHS.

Shoot the messenger. It's easier.


0
Login to get fewer ads

Welsh NHS (n/t) on 21:20 - Nov 10max936

Welsh NHS on 21:17 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

I had a Turkish neighbour for a while. He told me Turkish health service was way better than the NHS.

Shoot the messenger. It's easier.


The best thing you can do is naff off back over there and stay there, its sooooo much better than here in your blurred eyes.
[Post edited 10 Nov 21:22]
0
Welsh NHS on 21:27 - Nov 10Whiterockin

Welsh NHS on 21:17 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

I had a Turkish neighbour for a while. He told me Turkish health service was way better than the NHS.

Shoot the messenger. It's easier.


I have been told that Turkish retirees only pay about 10% of prescription charges.
1
Welsh NHS on 08:12 - Nov 11SullutaCreturned

Welsh NHS on 21:27 - Nov 10 by Whiterockin

I have been told that Turkish retirees only pay about 10% of prescription charges.


AI says,

If you are a Turkish citizen or a legal resident enrolled in Turkey's public health insurance system (Sosyal Güvenlik Kurumu), the state covers roughly 80% to 90% of the cost of approved prescription medications. Patients generally only pay a small copayment or a fraction of the retail price.

Maybe Res, you should go to Turkey and tell them people should pay the FULL cost of prescriptions?

Maybe you should look to the USA to see what being made to pay for everything looks like? Every year more than 500,000 people go bankruot because of medical bills. That number is rising too. 40% of all bankruptcies in the states are because of medical bills.
1
Welsh NHS on 08:29 - Nov 11SullutaCreturned

Welsh NHS on 15:28 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

11 % in England do pay prescription charges and this goes back on to the sysm. 11% uplift compared to Wales. This is a huge figure. About £70min Wales. £1.4 billion in England

From what I read everyone over 60 in England gets free prescriptions..It is madness . These are among the richest people on the planet.
Effectively many millionaires getting free drugs . It's nuts.

I stick to the topic and do not debate whether you are a dimwit or not. Some people on here might be vulnerable..

I do know one thing. You can only debate properly if I agree with you. The NHS is sacred and emotive and is actually based in international standard very cheap.

Too cheap..
.


You think that every over 60 in England is rich? There are some who are very rich obviously but many are dirt poor too.
Making them all pay would push very many people into health poverty and see many need more expensive hospital treatment, something you constantly fail to understand. You would condemn many to an early death, do I assume you are ok with that?

The loan system you suggest is entirely unworkable because people will find ways around it. people are clever like that. Besides, when do they start it? You cannot impose tht on people whpo have a social contract right now so you'd be condemning our under 18's to the system.

There is so much more in the welfare stae where savings can be made without condemning people to poor health and worse lives.
0
Welsh NHS on 08:52 - Nov 11max936

Welsh NHS on 08:29 - Nov 11 by SullutaCreturned

You think that every over 60 in England is rich? There are some who are very rich obviously but many are dirt poor too.
Making them all pay would push very many people into health poverty and see many need more expensive hospital treatment, something you constantly fail to understand. You would condemn many to an early death, do I assume you are ok with that?

The loan system you suggest is entirely unworkable because people will find ways around it. people are clever like that. Besides, when do they start it? You cannot impose tht on people whpo have a social contract right now so you'd be condemning our under 18's to the system.

There is so much more in the welfare stae where savings can be made without condemning people to poor health and worse lives.


What's that saying about arguing with idiots again, time to leave the idiot to drown in his own delusion, Cat.
0
Welsh NHS on 09:12 - Nov 11Whiterockin

Welsh NHS on 08:12 - Nov 11 by SullutaCreturned

AI says,

If you are a Turkish citizen or a legal resident enrolled in Turkey's public health insurance system (Sosyal Güvenlik Kurumu), the state covers roughly 80% to 90% of the cost of approved prescription medications. Patients generally only pay a small copayment or a fraction of the retail price.

Maybe Res, you should go to Turkey and tell them people should pay the FULL cost of prescriptions?

Maybe you should look to the USA to see what being made to pay for everything looks like? Every year more than 500,000 people go bankruot because of medical bills. That number is rising too. 40% of all bankruptcies in the states are because of medical bills.


Yet another country realising it is cheaper to give free medication than repair the damage later.
[Post edited 11 Nov 9:12]
1
Welsh NHS on 09:22 - Nov 11Demitrius

Most pensioners struggle as far as I can see both in England and in Wales.

Yes they own their own homes because working hard and owning your home was normal back in the day not a pipedream.

A sick idea to punish the elderly. Get the young lazy feckwits on benefits off the sofa and into work. That will save a few bob.

“Cunnilingus and Psychiatry brought us to this …”

2
Welsh NHS on 09:56 - Nov 11onehunglow

Welsh NHS on 08:52 - Nov 11 by max936

What's that saying about arguing with idiots again, time to leave the idiot to drown in his own delusion, Cat.


They wear you down ,then beat you with experience

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
Welsh NHS on 23:39 - Nov 11ReslovenSwan1

Welsh NHS on 08:29 - Nov 11 by SullutaCreturned

You think that every over 60 in England is rich? There are some who are very rich obviously but many are dirt poor too.
Making them all pay would push very many people into health poverty and see many need more expensive hospital treatment, something you constantly fail to understand. You would condemn many to an early death, do I assume you are ok with that?

The loan system you suggest is entirely unworkable because people will find ways around it. people are clever like that. Besides, when do they start it? You cannot impose tht on people whpo have a social contract right now so you'd be condemning our under 18's to the system.

There is so much more in the welfare stae where savings can be made without condemning people to poor health and worse lives.


The NHS is performing poorly on n most cases because it is underfunded..

Most pensioners are rich in assets but in some cases not cash rich. Many down size and liberate cash. Many do not and hold on to very expensive property and live in austerity to save the property value for the offspring often tax free in Wales ..

Whan a person needs drugs they will find the money. Over 60 year old are the wealthiest demographic the UK. Mortgage paid money in the bank. There is no need to subsidize prescription drugs in most cases.

If an 75 year old has no cash but a big property HM Government can set up a scheme for cheap 'equity release' without excessive charges to cover costs.

This would liberate £632 m in Wales and around £12 billion or so in England. The winners of not doing this are the children of the pensioners who get a chunky inheritance tax free. The losers are the sick and dying who did not get a fully funded service because funds were diverted to buy drugs pensions can afford themselves.

Just an opinion no need for abuse.



.
[Post edited 11 Nov 23:42]

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

0
Welsh NHS on 23:50 - Nov 11ReslovenSwan1

Welsh NHS on 09:22 - Nov 11 by Demitrius

Most pensioners struggle as far as I can see both in England and in Wales.

Yes they own their own homes because working hard and owning your home was normal back in the day not a pipedream.

A sick idea to punish the elderly. Get the young lazy feckwits on benefits off the sofa and into work. That will save a few bob.


Different subject. Mobilising £623m in Wales from abolishing prescription charges would create a few thousand new health care jobs I would think.

My folks next door neighbour is a lad that like a pint and failed to keep any skilled job despite training course and does a bit of gardening. He lives in his late Mums house for free and other cash from various inheritances.
.

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

-2
Welsh NHS on 12:49 - Nov 12max936

Welsh NHS on 23:50 - Nov 11 by ReslovenSwan1

Different subject. Mobilising £623m in Wales from abolishing prescription charges would create a few thousand new health care jobs I would think.

My folks next door neighbour is a lad that like a pint and failed to keep any skilled job despite training course and does a bit of gardening. He lives in his late Mums house for free and other cash from various inheritances.
.


"My folks next door neighbour is a lad that like a pint and failed to keep any skilled job despite training course and does a bit of gardening. He lives in his late Mums house for free and other cash from various inheritances."

He's self sufficient then so what's your problem, in any case its none of your business and you shouldn't be posting someone else's business on here!
0
Welsh NHS on 12:52 - Nov 12max936

Welsh NHS on 23:39 - Nov 11 by ReslovenSwan1

The NHS is performing poorly on n most cases because it is underfunded..

Most pensioners are rich in assets but in some cases not cash rich. Many down size and liberate cash. Many do not and hold on to very expensive property and live in austerity to save the property value for the offspring often tax free in Wales ..

Whan a person needs drugs they will find the money. Over 60 year old are the wealthiest demographic the UK. Mortgage paid money in the bank. There is no need to subsidize prescription drugs in most cases.

If an 75 year old has no cash but a big property HM Government can set up a scheme for cheap 'equity release' without excessive charges to cover costs.

This would liberate £632 m in Wales and around £12 billion or so in England. The winners of not doing this are the children of the pensioners who get a chunky inheritance tax free. The losers are the sick and dying who did not get a fully funded service because funds were diverted to buy drugs pensions can afford themselves.

Just an opinion no need for abuse.



.
[Post edited 11 Nov 23:42]


There's no abuse in SullutaCreturned post, stop making things up!
0
Welsh NHS on 14:53 - Nov 12SullutaCreturned

Welsh NHS on 23:39 - Nov 11 by ReslovenSwan1

The NHS is performing poorly on n most cases because it is underfunded..

Most pensioners are rich in assets but in some cases not cash rich. Many down size and liberate cash. Many do not and hold on to very expensive property and live in austerity to save the property value for the offspring often tax free in Wales ..

Whan a person needs drugs they will find the money. Over 60 year old are the wealthiest demographic the UK. Mortgage paid money in the bank. There is no need to subsidize prescription drugs in most cases.

If an 75 year old has no cash but a big property HM Government can set up a scheme for cheap 'equity release' without excessive charges to cover costs.

This would liberate £632 m in Wales and around £12 billion or so in England. The winners of not doing this are the children of the pensioners who get a chunky inheritance tax free. The losers are the sick and dying who did not get a fully funded service because funds were diverted to buy drugs pensions can afford themselves.

Just an opinion no need for abuse.



.
[Post edited 11 Nov 23:42]


The NHS is badly run. there is a lot of waste. Ask any staff member.

The Welsh are all subject to inheritance tax which is not devolved, it is controlled by Westminster so NO, it is not often "tax free" unless it's below the threshold.

The over 60's being rich, how much are the figures skewed by the very wealthy, by the top 10%?
Saying when a person needs drugs they will find the money is just very cynical, what do they go withoiut to fund those life saving drugs, food, heating or maybe don't pay the mortgage.

You say,
This would liberate £632 m in Wales and around £12 billion or so in England. The winners of not doing this are the children of the pensioners who get a chunky inheritance tax free. The losers are the sick and dying who did not get a fully funded service because funds were diverted to buy drugs pensions can afford themselves.

Which yet again contains lies. Welsh residents pay inheritance tax so it is not free unless they are below the threshold, don't lie. Why should Welsh residents not be allowed to leave money or a property for their children?
And yet again you ignore a simple basic fact, free prescriptions actually saves the NHS money every year. I'd like you to answer that, why would you make everybody pay when the evidence says free scripts is cost effective and saves more than it costs? Why do you keep ignoring that point?
0
Welsh NHS on 15:18 - Nov 12max936

Welsh NHS on 14:53 - Nov 12 by SullutaCreturned

The NHS is badly run. there is a lot of waste. Ask any staff member.

The Welsh are all subject to inheritance tax which is not devolved, it is controlled by Westminster so NO, it is not often "tax free" unless it's below the threshold.

The over 60's being rich, how much are the figures skewed by the very wealthy, by the top 10%?
Saying when a person needs drugs they will find the money is just very cynical, what do they go withoiut to fund those life saving drugs, food, heating or maybe don't pay the mortgage.

You say,
This would liberate £632 m in Wales and around £12 billion or so in England. The winners of not doing this are the children of the pensioners who get a chunky inheritance tax free. The losers are the sick and dying who did not get a fully funded service because funds were diverted to buy drugs pensions can afford themselves.

Which yet again contains lies. Welsh residents pay inheritance tax so it is not free unless they are below the threshold, don't lie. Why should Welsh residents not be allowed to leave money or a property for their children?
And yet again you ignore a simple basic fact, free prescriptions actually saves the NHS money every year. I'd like you to answer that, why would you make everybody pay when the evidence says free scripts is cost effective and saves more than it costs? Why do you keep ignoring that point?


"Why do you keep ignoring that point?"

It doesn't fit his attention seeking agenda.
2
Welsh NHS on 19:11 - Nov 12ReslovenSwan1

Welsh NHS on 15:18 - Nov 12 by max936

"Why do you keep ignoring that point?"

It doesn't fit his attention seeking agenda.


As you said you are no one's side kick.i agree with you. You just act like one.

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

0
Welsh NHS on 19:28 - Nov 12ReslovenSwan1

Welsh NHS on 14:53 - Nov 12 by SullutaCreturned

The NHS is badly run. there is a lot of waste. Ask any staff member.

The Welsh are all subject to inheritance tax which is not devolved, it is controlled by Westminster so NO, it is not often "tax free" unless it's below the threshold.

The over 60's being rich, how much are the figures skewed by the very wealthy, by the top 10%?
Saying when a person needs drugs they will find the money is just very cynical, what do they go withoiut to fund those life saving drugs, food, heating or maybe don't pay the mortgage.

You say,
This would liberate £632 m in Wales and around £12 billion or so in England. The winners of not doing this are the children of the pensioners who get a chunky inheritance tax free. The losers are the sick and dying who did not get a fully funded service because funds were diverted to buy drugs pensions can afford themselves.

Which yet again contains lies. Welsh residents pay inheritance tax so it is not free unless they are below the threshold, don't lie. Why should Welsh residents not be allowed to leave money or a property for their children?
And yet again you ignore a simple basic fact, free prescriptions actually saves the NHS money every year. I'd like you to answer that, why would you make everybody pay when the evidence says free scripts is cost effective and saves more than it costs? Why do you keep ignoring that point?


Ok let's assess.

The standard UK Inheritance Tax (IHT) nil-rate band threshold is £325,000 per person.

• Nil-Rate Band (NRB): £325,000 is tax-free for every individual.
• Residence Nil-Rate Band (RNRB): An extra £175,000 applies if you leave your main home to direct descendants (such as children or grandchildren), bringing the individual total to £500,000.

I would suggest most Welsh people are under this limit.

I gave data for all 65. + Pensioners and the vast major own property outright. It was not averaged so your point does not stack up.

Whether free prescriptions save the NHS money is a debatable point. It presupposes that patients who have to pay will opt not to take medication to save money and end up hospitalised earlier. This would of course be incredibly stupid and raises issues of the " nanny state". It is the same option that smokers and drinkers take.

The vast majority of citizens would pay.
[Post edited 12 Nov 20:00]

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

0
Welsh NHS on 20:00 - Nov 12Whiterockin

Welsh NHS on 19:28 - Nov 12 by ReslovenSwan1

Ok let's assess.

The standard UK Inheritance Tax (IHT) nil-rate band threshold is £325,000 per person.

• Nil-Rate Band (NRB): £325,000 is tax-free for every individual.
• Residence Nil-Rate Band (RNRB): An extra £175,000 applies if you leave your main home to direct descendants (such as children or grandchildren), bringing the individual total to £500,000.

I would suggest most Welsh people are under this limit.

I gave data for all 65. + Pensioners and the vast major own property outright. It was not averaged so your point does not stack up.

Whether free prescriptions save the NHS money is a debatable point. It presupposes that patients who have to pay will opt not to take medication to save money and end up hospitalised earlier. This would of course be incredibly stupid and raises issues of the " nanny state". It is the same option that smokers and drinkers take.

The vast majority of citizens would pay.
[Post edited 12 Nov 20:00]


As a married couple its £1M.
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026