Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Watson leaves. Who’s next? 09:03 - Nov 22 with 5958 views442Dale


Poll: Greatest Ever Dale Game

4
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:10 - Nov 22Albert_Whitehurst

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:02 - Nov 22 by D_Alien

Just another thought: i wonder whether our injury record will now "improve" once a new manager/head coach is installed, and with him, presumably his own backroom team (no mention of them.in the short statement by the club)


Was surprised also at no mention of Assistant or Head Coach in that statement (whether or not they’d gone or were in caretaker charge)
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:28 - Nov 22Edindale

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:02 - Nov 22 by D_Alien

Just another thought: i wonder whether our injury record will now "improve" once a new manager/head coach is installed, and with him, presumably his own backroom team (no mention of them.in the short statement by the club)


Relief for the supporters, the club and IW himself who has acted with class and integrity through a difficult period despite maintaining his misguided philosophies on how we should play. I hope he does well in his next appointment.

Hopefully the directors will be busy this week, as at the moment it is unclear what the caretaker arrangements are and who is taking training etc. They also need to understand from potential candidates what their appetite is for managing the team.

The squad needs a fundamental re-appraisal although I agree we have some useful players who could help us climb the table if fit and properly utilised. Some good suggestions have already been made on this thread but please keep Tasker if at all possible.

If playing budgets/money becomes an issue as undoubtedly it will, I would be inclined to give Hendo an enhanced role as player coach in the run up to the transfer window. Not sure what we would have to lose in doing this which hopefully would free up funds for terminations and transfers.

Don't expect much before Barnet but if we could beat Newport we may have a chance to bolster the coffers and restore a feel good factor.

UTD
2
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:42 - Nov 22dawlishdale

Good decision by the board albeit a few weeks too late. Wish IW (and hopefully his backroom staff) all the best for the future but clearly the Efl was too big a jump.

Maynard for me ...as it was when Jim left us. Woodman a decent second bet. No to the bucket Lowe.

We need someone to up the fitness levels whilst protecting the players from injuries. We do have a squad capable of mid table imho but haven't had much leadership.
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:48 - Nov 22442Dale

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:42 - Nov 22 by dawlishdale

Good decision by the board albeit a few weeks too late. Wish IW (and hopefully his backroom staff) all the best for the future but clearly the Efl was too big a jump.

Maynard for me ...as it was when Jim left us. Woodman a decent second bet. No to the bucket Lowe.

We need someone to up the fitness levels whilst protecting the players from injuries. We do have a squad capable of mid table imho but haven't had much leadership.


McNulty left in early June, Watson was appointed on the 9th of that month. Maynard was still at York until the last week of July.

Poll: Greatest Ever Dale Game

1
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:18 - Nov 22samueloneils

Does anyone know why Maynard was sacked? Seemed strange at the time and heard nothing since.

At the same time Harrison Male had his contract terminated, having been the most successful keeper in the National League . I couldn`t understand why the Dale didn`t go for a successful 25 year old, and it was quite a while before Tranmere signed him up, since when he has done well ,according to my Tranmere friend.
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:24 - Nov 22Standishdale

I'm swaying towards Maynard too. York played good football last season and they had some big units in the squad which I guess he likes and we always seem to exclude. I suppose we'll all have to sit and wait.........
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:26 - Nov 22RippDale

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:18 - Nov 22 by samueloneils

Does anyone know why Maynard was sacked? Seemed strange at the time and heard nothing since.

At the same time Harrison Male had his contract terminated, having been the most successful keeper in the National League . I couldn`t understand why the Dale didn`t go for a successful 25 year old, and it was quite a while before Tranmere signed him up, since when he has done well ,according to my Tranmere friend.


It sounded like their owner was playing football manager and having a say in who they were signing and the new guy is a mate. Male was after 5k a week was the talk at the time
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:46 - Nov 2249thseason

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 12:02 - Nov 22 by D_Alien

Just another thought: i wonder whether our injury record will now "improve" once a new manager/head coach is installed, and with him, presumably his own backroom team (no mention of them.in the short statement by the club)


The step up to league 2 is hard...you have to be able to compete physically as the first order of business, only then do you get to play a more technical brand of football. L2 clubs are awash with strapping, 6 foot tall lads, 25 - 30 years old, who can run, tackle and win headers. Add in a potent striker and the means to feed him and you are in with a shout..

The simple statistics tell us we can't defend well enough and can't score enough goals to mitigate a leaky defence. We were in trouble from day one. Finding a manager capable of fixing it is going to be very difficult and probably expensive and thats assuming there is a manager prepared to take on the task.

We now have a 30 game season to get 40+ points, taking us to around 55 and probable L2 survival.. 1.25 per game compared to just under 1 point per game so far so a 25% improvement in results, not at all impossible but it will require an improvement on Brown as striker/ target/ poacher, more minutes for Henderson and at least 1 more striker. And it seems like Dieseruvwe and Rodney are not going to be much help based on 16 games so far, I think National League is their ceiling.....Shutting the back door would also be high on the agenda, 4 at the back or a 3 with wingbacks with some central cover in midfield and above all a sense of playing safe passes, reducing risk and a touch of the old Peter Valentine approach to defending.. " if in doubt hoof it into row Z". Yesterday exposed the whole problem, it started badly , they rescued a potential win and then lost, couldnt even settle for what would have been a decent point
The new manager has to be a pragmatist, a good explainer, single minded and prepared to make neccessary changes for 30 games... keeping us in L2 is job done and the only important metric...
0
Login to get fewer ads

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:56 - Nov 22Daley_Lama

Whoever comes in is going to have little wriggle room until at least January, possibly longer.

We’re over-stocked with wingers and short on striker/full back through injuries. Various players were tried in the 10 position with limited success.

Shoring up the defence is number 1 priority and Barnet a tough baptism for whoever is in charge.

Poll: DF in or out

0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:59 - Nov 22442Dale

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:46 - Nov 22 by 49thseason

The step up to league 2 is hard...you have to be able to compete physically as the first order of business, only then do you get to play a more technical brand of football. L2 clubs are awash with strapping, 6 foot tall lads, 25 - 30 years old, who can run, tackle and win headers. Add in a potent striker and the means to feed him and you are in with a shout..

The simple statistics tell us we can't defend well enough and can't score enough goals to mitigate a leaky defence. We were in trouble from day one. Finding a manager capable of fixing it is going to be very difficult and probably expensive and thats assuming there is a manager prepared to take on the task.

We now have a 30 game season to get 40+ points, taking us to around 55 and probable L2 survival.. 1.25 per game compared to just under 1 point per game so far so a 25% improvement in results, not at all impossible but it will require an improvement on Brown as striker/ target/ poacher, more minutes for Henderson and at least 1 more striker. And it seems like Dieseruvwe and Rodney are not going to be much help based on 16 games so far, I think National League is their ceiling.....Shutting the back door would also be high on the agenda, 4 at the back or a 3 with wingbacks with some central cover in midfield and above all a sense of playing safe passes, reducing risk and a touch of the old Peter Valentine approach to defending.. " if in doubt hoof it into row Z". Yesterday exposed the whole problem, it started badly , they rescued a potential win and then lost, couldnt even settle for what would have been a decent point
The new manager has to be a pragmatist, a good explainer, single minded and prepared to make neccessary changes for 30 games... keeping us in L2 is job done and the only important metric...


Which teams are full of these strapping, 6ft tall 25-30 year old players who run, tackle and win headers?
The only one I’m aware of specifically are Oldham. Look how they’re doing. There may be others, so happy to be wrong, presumably there are other examples?

York certainly aren’t. They started last week with a smaller defender (Fallowfield) in the back three, two wing backs who aren’t that big, a centre forward in Pearce who is no bigger than our forwards. Boateng is more physical in midfield but he’s not featured much until recently. The only other starter they had who could partially fit the bill is Banks. He’s 34 and more of a creative player as well.

The York comparison being the obvious as they came up with us and would presumably recruit to fit the league. They are 5th and all the players mentioned were at the club last season.
[Post edited 22 Nov 14:01]

Poll: Greatest Ever Dale Game

0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 14:58 - Nov 22Philomena

Hilly & Flicker if they would do it until the end of the season with a remit to keep us up, and they would keep us up! then re assess the way forward.
In our current position its sometimes better the devil you know.
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 15:20 - Nov 22lizard

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 14:58 - Nov 22 by Philomena

Hilly & Flicker if they would do it until the end of the season with a remit to keep us up, and they would keep us up! then re assess the way forward.
In our current position its sometimes better the devil you know.


That’s what I’d do. Need to consolidate with people who know the club. Then regroup at the end of the season hopefully still in EFL2 and make a longer term appointment. I do feel there’s a role somewhere here for Hendo in keeping us up, as part of the back-room.
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 15:35 - Nov 2249thseason

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 13:59 - Nov 22 by 442Dale

Which teams are full of these strapping, 6ft tall 25-30 year old players who run, tackle and win headers?
The only one I’m aware of specifically are Oldham. Look how they’re doing. There may be others, so happy to be wrong, presumably there are other examples?

York certainly aren’t. They started last week with a smaller defender (Fallowfield) in the back three, two wing backs who aren’t that big, a centre forward in Pearce who is no bigger than our forwards. Boateng is more physical in midfield but he’s not featured much until recently. The only other starter they had who could partially fit the bill is Banks. He’s 34 and more of a creative player as well.

The York comparison being the obvious as they came up with us and would presumably recruit to fit the league. They are 5th and all the players mentioned were at the club last season.
[Post edited 22 Nov 14:01]


Key Squad Insights

• Height Advantage: Rochdale held a noticeable physical advantage in height (+4.9 cm on average), anchored by centre-back pairing Aden Flint (197 cm) and Kaiden Wilson (191 cm), which helped them edge the aerial duels 52% to 48%.
• Age & Experience: While WhoScored's match centre lists Rochdale's broader matchday squad average slightly higher (27.3)—boosted by 41-year-old substitute Ian Henderson—York City fielded the older starting eleven on the day, featuring seven starters aged 27 or older.
• Youth Factor: Both sides started 21-year-old goalkeepers or defenders—Sam Waller (23), Kaiden Wilson (21), Kane Taylor (21), Zain Silcott-Duberry (21), and Dajaune Brown (21) for Rochdale, alongside Alfie McNally (21) and Zak Johnson (21) for York.

Flint and Henderson change the stats, particularly height and experience, we played 4 21 year olds and a 23 year old keeper against York, who had two U21s
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 15:47 - Nov 22442Dale

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 15:35 - Nov 22 by 49thseason

Key Squad Insights

• Height Advantage: Rochdale held a noticeable physical advantage in height (+4.9 cm on average), anchored by centre-back pairing Aden Flint (197 cm) and Kaiden Wilson (191 cm), which helped them edge the aerial duels 52% to 48%.
• Age & Experience: While WhoScored's match centre lists Rochdale's broader matchday squad average slightly higher (27.3)—boosted by 41-year-old substitute Ian Henderson—York City fielded the older starting eleven on the day, featuring seven starters aged 27 or older.
• Youth Factor: Both sides started 21-year-old goalkeepers or defenders—Sam Waller (23), Kaiden Wilson (21), Kane Taylor (21), Zain Silcott-Duberry (21), and Dajaune Brown (21) for Rochdale, alongside Alfie McNally (21) and Zak Johnson (21) for York.

Flint and Henderson change the stats, particularly height and experience, we played 4 21 year olds and a 23 year old keeper against York, who had two U21s


So does that confirm we had players with a height advantage over York yet still lost?

Was just wondering which League 2 teams are “ awash with strapping, 6 foot tall lads”?

That’s yet to be established.

We’ve confirmed that York, in 5th place, aren’t. So why do we need to be to compete?

Poll: Greatest Ever Dale Game

0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:06 - Nov 22EllDale

It would be interesting to see, hypothetically, if say Hendo and EEL were appointed caretakers, what team and formation they would pick for Saturday.
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:21 - Nov 2249thseason

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 15:47 - Nov 22 by 442Dale

So does that confirm we had players with a height advantage over York yet still lost?

Was just wondering which League 2 teams are “ awash with strapping, 6 foot tall lads”?

That’s yet to be established.

We’ve confirmed that York, in 5th place, aren’t. So why do we need to be to compete?


I think it means you cant have more than a couple of young inexperienced players in a side and go up against players with far more experience even if you can match them for size,
" Rochdale’s 27.1 average age masks a sharp generational split: they boast the oldest attacking unit (28.9 yrs, featuring 41-year-old Ian Henderson, 34-year-old Jamie Paterson, and 31-year-old Emmanuel Dieseruvwe) alongside the youngest goalkeeping department (20.8 yrs, led by 19-year-old Brighton loanee Nils Ramming). By contrast, Barnet (26.1 yrs) and York City (26.8 yrs) concentrate their rosters in the 24–29 athletic peak across every line. Salford, Barnet, and York are built around tighter, prime-age cores.

• Top 3 Core XI Average: ~235 career EFL appearances per player
• Salford City leads the division—regular starters Will Norris, Luke Garbutt, Will Aimson, Jorge Grant, and Daniel Udoh alone account for over 1,600 combined EFL appearances.
• Chesterfield pairs seasoned midfielders Tom Naylor (35, 450+ EFL games) and Liam Mandeville (29, 300+ senior games) with prime-age attackers Josh Koroma and Dilan Markanday.
• Barnet boasts the most balanced "prime-age" core—players like Brandon Comley (31), Charlie Lakin (27), Tom Knowles (28), and Idris Kanu (26) all sit squarely in the 200–300 career senior appearances bracket

Comparing the 11 most-used players for each side during the 2026/27 campaign so far, Rochdale's core XI averages ~24.8 years of age and ~130 career EFL appearances per player, whereas Salford City's core XI averages ~28.3 years and ~275 career EFL appearances.
That creates a 3.5-year age gap and more than double the EFL experience in Salford’s favor—largely because Rochdale’s heaviest minutes are carried by U21 Premier League loanees and newly promoted signings, while Salford’s regular starters are established Championship and League One veterans.
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:48 - Nov 22442Dale

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:21 - Nov 22 by 49thseason

I think it means you cant have more than a couple of young inexperienced players in a side and go up against players with far more experience even if you can match them for size,
" Rochdale’s 27.1 average age masks a sharp generational split: they boast the oldest attacking unit (28.9 yrs, featuring 41-year-old Ian Henderson, 34-year-old Jamie Paterson, and 31-year-old Emmanuel Dieseruvwe) alongside the youngest goalkeeping department (20.8 yrs, led by 19-year-old Brighton loanee Nils Ramming). By contrast, Barnet (26.1 yrs) and York City (26.8 yrs) concentrate their rosters in the 24–29 athletic peak across every line. Salford, Barnet, and York are built around tighter, prime-age cores.

• Top 3 Core XI Average: ~235 career EFL appearances per player
• Salford City leads the division—regular starters Will Norris, Luke Garbutt, Will Aimson, Jorge Grant, and Daniel Udoh alone account for over 1,600 combined EFL appearances.
• Chesterfield pairs seasoned midfielders Tom Naylor (35, 450+ EFL games) and Liam Mandeville (29, 300+ senior games) with prime-age attackers Josh Koroma and Dilan Markanday.
• Barnet boasts the most balanced "prime-age" core—players like Brandon Comley (31), Charlie Lakin (27), Tom Knowles (28), and Idris Kanu (26) all sit squarely in the 200–300 career senior appearances bracket

Comparing the 11 most-used players for each side during the 2026/27 campaign so far, Rochdale's core XI averages ~24.8 years of age and ~130 career EFL appearances per player, whereas Salford City's core XI averages ~28.3 years and ~275 career EFL appearances.
That creates a 3.5-year age gap and more than double the EFL experience in Salford’s favor—largely because Rochdale’s heaviest minutes are carried by U21 Premier League loanees and newly promoted signings, while Salford’s regular starters are established Championship and League One veterans.


So we don’t need lots of players who are strapping and 6ft to compete in L2 then?

I didn’t need to visit AI to have that opinion, just forming it on what we’ve seen so far this season.

There’s enough in this squad, to stay up and compete however it will need some work doing to get the balance right. Two defenders, one who can play various roles and a centre forward would help.

There was no original discussion on EFL experience, so not sure why that’s the subject now. Oh, and Ollie Pearce hadn’t played one minute in the Football League before this season.

Poll: Greatest Ever Dale Game

0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:52 - Nov 22TVOS1907

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:21 - Nov 22 by 49thseason

I think it means you cant have more than a couple of young inexperienced players in a side and go up against players with far more experience even if you can match them for size,
" Rochdale’s 27.1 average age masks a sharp generational split: they boast the oldest attacking unit (28.9 yrs, featuring 41-year-old Ian Henderson, 34-year-old Jamie Paterson, and 31-year-old Emmanuel Dieseruvwe) alongside the youngest goalkeeping department (20.8 yrs, led by 19-year-old Brighton loanee Nils Ramming). By contrast, Barnet (26.1 yrs) and York City (26.8 yrs) concentrate their rosters in the 24–29 athletic peak across every line. Salford, Barnet, and York are built around tighter, prime-age cores.

• Top 3 Core XI Average: ~235 career EFL appearances per player
• Salford City leads the division—regular starters Will Norris, Luke Garbutt, Will Aimson, Jorge Grant, and Daniel Udoh alone account for over 1,600 combined EFL appearances.
• Chesterfield pairs seasoned midfielders Tom Naylor (35, 450+ EFL games) and Liam Mandeville (29, 300+ senior games) with prime-age attackers Josh Koroma and Dilan Markanday.
• Barnet boasts the most balanced "prime-age" core—players like Brandon Comley (31), Charlie Lakin (27), Tom Knowles (28), and Idris Kanu (26) all sit squarely in the 200–300 career senior appearances bracket

Comparing the 11 most-used players for each side during the 2026/27 campaign so far, Rochdale's core XI averages ~24.8 years of age and ~130 career EFL appearances per player, whereas Salford City's core XI averages ~28.3 years and ~275 career EFL appearances.
That creates a 3.5-year age gap and more than double the EFL experience in Salford’s favor—largely because Rochdale’s heaviest minutes are carried by U21 Premier League loanees and newly promoted signings, while Salford’s regular starters are established Championship and League One veterans.


Even more terrific.

Maestro? No. Elite? No. Heavyweight poster? No. Able to be rational and not over-react to individual results? Yes.

0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:54 - Nov 22Albert_Whitehurst

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:06 - Nov 22 by EllDale

It would be interesting to see, hypothetically, if say Hendo and EEL were appointed caretakers, what team and formation they would pick for Saturday.


Magnay and Mangan are still at the club it would seem.
0
Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 18:11 - Nov 22EllDale

Watson leaves. Who’s next? on 17:54 - Nov 22 by Albert_Whitehurst

Magnay and Mangan are still at the club it would seem.


Be even more interesting to see the team and how it’s setup then.
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026