Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
UK/EU negotiations 10:12 - Nov 9 with 3364 viewsjohnlangy

Unlike posters on other threads who already have strong opinions about the possible deal that the UK/EU may come up with i'm going to wait and see what the proposed deal ls.

It always surprises me that so many people form such strongly held opinions months in advance of knowing what the suggested deal is.
0
UK/EU negotiations on 10:24 - Nov 9Whiterockin

When other EU countries say they want us back for the money we put in, in my opinion it outlines the way it will go.
1
UK/EU negotiations on 10:54 - Nov 9johnlangy

UK/EU negotiations on 10:24 - Nov 9 by Whiterockin

When other EU countries say they want us back for the money we put in, in my opinion it outlines the way it will go.


Maybe. But we'll see. If it's a crock of you know what then we'll stay away.
0
UK/EU negotiations on 11:18 - Nov 9majorraglan

UK/EU negotiations on 10:54 - Nov 9 by johnlangy

Maybe. But we'll see. If it's a crock of you know what then we'll stay away.


I think that’s a sensible pragmatic approach. There has to substantial benefits for us, otherwise there’s no point in doing anything.
1
UK/EU negotiations on 11:24 - Nov 9Whiterockin

UK/EU negotiations on 11:18 - Nov 9 by majorraglan

I think that’s a sensible pragmatic approach. There has to substantial benefits for us, otherwise there’s no point in doing anything.


Exactly.
1
UK/EU negotiations on 11:30 - Nov 9Whiterockin

An alternative view. But it is in the Daily Mail.

Norway's PM warns Britain NOT to follow its example by joining the EU single market


https://mol.im/a/16277741
0
UK/EU negotiations on 13:21 - Nov 9JJBomber

UK/EU negotiations on 10:54 - Nov 9 by johnlangy

Maybe. But we'll see. If it's a crock of you know what then we'll stay away.


It will be and we won't!
1
UK/EU negotiations on 15:41 - Nov 9AnotherJohn

It is fair enough to point out that we don't have full final details of the proposed SPS deal yet, but there is a real draft document, parts of which have been leaked to journalists ranging from Sky News to the Guardian. When extended verbatim extracts have been reported, it doesn't seem to me to be unreasonable to comment. I prefer that to blind faith.

https://news.sky.com/video/wha

https://www.theguardian.com/po
0
UK/EU negotiations on 16:10 - Nov 9max936

UK/EU negotiations on 10:24 - Nov 9 by Whiterockin

When other EU countries say they want us back for the money we put in, in my opinion it outlines the way it will go.


Exactly Whitey.
1
Login to get fewer ads

UK/EU negotiations on 15:13 - Nov 10SullutaCreturned

UK/EU negotiations on 10:24 - Nov 9 by Whiterockin

When other EU countries say they want us back for the money we put in, in my opinion it outlines the way it will go.


It was the Czech PM, he said he'd back us rejoining because "we need more money" which we should all pay attention to.
1
UK/EU negotiations on 17:34 - Nov 10ReslovenSwan1

Immigration debate has always focussed on skilled workers . We apparently did not need unqualified workers .

This I believe was a myth. Before Brexit unskilled Europeans were coming here to earn a few bob and learn English and work in hospitality. We NEEEDED unskilled workers. Waiters cooks bottle washers barmen. Also the 40,000 Romanian and Bulgarian agricultural workers and Poles in meat factories and care home workers .

When the British citizen kicked them out the Government had no option but to offer work visa s to Africans and Asians .

We did not respect our unskilled workforce pre Brexit. We never saw them about town because they were grafting.
[Post edited 10 Nov 18:22]

Wise sage since Toshack era
Poll: Do Swansea city have enough centre backs?

0
UK/EU negotiations on 18:35 - Nov 10majorraglan

UK/EU negotiations on 17:34 - Nov 10 by ReslovenSwan1

Immigration debate has always focussed on skilled workers . We apparently did not need unqualified workers .

This I believe was a myth. Before Brexit unskilled Europeans were coming here to earn a few bob and learn English and work in hospitality. We NEEEDED unskilled workers. Waiters cooks bottle washers barmen. Also the 40,000 Romanian and Bulgarian agricultural workers and Poles in meat factories and care home workers .

When the British citizen kicked them out the Government had no option but to offer work visa s to Africans and Asians .

We did not respect our unskilled workforce pre Brexit. We never saw them about town because they were grafting.
[Post edited 10 Nov 18:22]


We still need unskilled workers, our abattoirs, food processing plants, food making factories, recycling centres, farms, orchards are all full of overseas workers. And why? Because they can’t get Brits to work there.

I occasionally have to visit a large factory in South Wales, 90% of its staff come from abroad because they can’t get Brits to work there. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a quite a tough gig, it’s 47 hours a week and the pay is a few shekels above minimum wage, but it’s a job which pays over £2.5k before tax etc if someone does the full 47 hours for the whole month. How can we have a situation where Brits won’t work for £2.5k a month?

If we didn’t have the unskilled workers, the local economy would lose a significant income, the exchequer would a shed load of tax, NI and tax on profit.

[Post edited 10 Nov 18:43]
1
UK/EU negotiations on 20:00 - Nov 10Gwyn737

UK/EU negotiations on 18:35 - Nov 10 by majorraglan

We still need unskilled workers, our abattoirs, food processing plants, food making factories, recycling centres, farms, orchards are all full of overseas workers. And why? Because they can’t get Brits to work there.

I occasionally have to visit a large factory in South Wales, 90% of its staff come from abroad because they can’t get Brits to work there. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a quite a tough gig, it’s 47 hours a week and the pay is a few shekels above minimum wage, but it’s a job which pays over £2.5k before tax etc if someone does the full 47 hours for the whole month. How can we have a situation where Brits won’t work for £2.5k a month?

If we didn’t have the unskilled workers, the local economy would lose a significant income, the exchequer would a shed load of tax, NI and tax on profit.

[Post edited 10 Nov 18:43]


People don’t seem to want to talk about that.

It can be tricky to talk about wider welfare issues as the conversation often gets turned back to immigration.

I’m not minimising the issues (particularly illegal) immigration brings, but when was the last time we had a thread about the NEET crisis? Or the possible over diagnosis of some mental health elements? Or the shocking academic performance of white free school meal kids?


The welfare bill is £340 billion. There’s a lot to talk about that’s not all immigration.
1
UK/EU negotiations on 20:19 - Nov 10Boundy

UK/EU negotiations on 10:54 - Nov 9 by johnlangy

Maybe. But we'll see. If it's a crock of you know what then we'll stay away.


I dont think we'll have the choice as its already decided and if you think I'm wrong ,fine but it was the people who voted out but the politicians who ballsed it up to suit their agenda this time its a different lot in and trying to suit their own agenda. We're just in the middle.

"In a free society, the State is the servant of the people—not the master."

0
UK/EU negotiations on 20:51 - Nov 10onehunglow

UK/EU negotiations on 18:35 - Nov 10 by majorraglan

We still need unskilled workers, our abattoirs, food processing plants, food making factories, recycling centres, farms, orchards are all full of overseas workers. And why? Because they can’t get Brits to work there.

I occasionally have to visit a large factory in South Wales, 90% of its staff come from abroad because they can’t get Brits to work there. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a quite a tough gig, it’s 47 hours a week and the pay is a few shekels above minimum wage, but it’s a job which pays over £2.5k before tax etc if someone does the full 47 hours for the whole month. How can we have a situation where Brits won’t work for £2.5k a month?

If we didn’t have the unskilled workers, the local economy would lose a significant income, the exchequer would a shed load of tax, NI and tax on profit.

[Post edited 10 Nov 18:43]


And why Brits don’t want to work on those jobs is our problem
We have created a nation of spoilt , entitled , shallow waifs who are utterly naive , more do than any previous generation
They have everything yet nothing to show for it

Many of us in industrial areas grew up quick and the closing of those industries is the reason we can’t find the will to work anymore in “ dirty” jobs

Poll: Christmas. Enjoyable or not

0
UK/EU negotiations on 20:55 - Nov 10Whiterockin

UK/EU negotiations on 20:51 - Nov 10 by onehunglow

And why Brits don’t want to work on those jobs is our problem
We have created a nation of spoilt , entitled , shallow waifs who are utterly naive , more do than any previous generation
They have everything yet nothing to show for it

Many of us in industrial areas grew up quick and the closing of those industries is the reason we can’t find the will to work anymore in “ dirty” jobs


If the government continue to reduce ambition and reward by taxation, we will shortly have a nation who refuse to work and do any job.
1
UK/EU negotiations on 21:37 - Nov 10max936

UK/EU negotiations on 18:35 - Nov 10 by majorraglan

We still need unskilled workers, our abattoirs, food processing plants, food making factories, recycling centres, farms, orchards are all full of overseas workers. And why? Because they can’t get Brits to work there.

I occasionally have to visit a large factory in South Wales, 90% of its staff come from abroad because they can’t get Brits to work there. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a quite a tough gig, it’s 47 hours a week and the pay is a few shekels above minimum wage, but it’s a job which pays over £2.5k before tax etc if someone does the full 47 hours for the whole month. How can we have a situation where Brits won’t work for £2.5k a month?

If we didn’t have the unskilled workers, the local economy would lose a significant income, the exchequer would a shed load of tax, NI and tax on profit.

[Post edited 10 Nov 18:43]


Would you work for 2,1/2 a month then and I take that, that is top line ?

They can probably get that on the rock and roll with the other add on's
[Post edited 10 Nov 21:38]
0
UK/EU negotiations on 08:55 - Nov 11AnotherJohn

To me, the large number of unemployed persons of working age, including NEETs, and high levels of immigration are closely connected. Immigration may not have been the historical triggering factor, but it helps create a pattern of possibilities and incentives that lead to undesirable outcomes. Cheap unskilled overseas labour, or skilled labour that can be recruited at a lower cost than training domestic labour, is a key factor in how we got to where we are now. Not all advanced societies go down a path where there are necessary jobs that are not done. Put crudely, the price mechanism (perhaps supplemented by other positive or negative incentives) will bring demand and supply into line. Other poorer nations do train doctors and nurses in sufficient numbers to meet domestic requirements (though countries like the UK sometimes lure them away). The UK never had a problem in the level of home applicants, yet chose not to fund sufficient training places. I suspect it is the same with apprenticeships or even opportunities given to recent graduates in technical subjects who would require the same salary as a more experienced immigrant. The point is not that this is necessary and unavoidable, but that it is unsustainable and cannot work in the long term. As a result of mass immigration, the foreign born population of the UK has risen sharply, increasing from about 5.3 million in 2004 to 13.1 million in 2024 according to official figures (which some say are an underestimate). Even after this influx we still have jobs that cannot be filled, both in the skilled and unskilled categories. Meanwhile an increasing % of the working age population does not work. It seems that if we continue current policies we need to continually renew the pool of recent arrivals, as each cohort performing the undesirable jobs stay in them only for a fairly short time before moving to other work or going on benefits. The definition of madness is doing the same things over and over again and believing the outcome will be different.
[Post edited 11 Nov 9:06]
0
UK/EU negotiations on 18:12 - Nov 11Dr_Winston

Burnham and co are so desperate to tie us back in with the EU they will allow themselves to be utterly shafted in any negotiation. It's basically treason.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

2
UK/EU negotiations on 18:33 - Nov 11max936

UK/EU negotiations on 18:12 - Nov 11 by Dr_Winston

Burnham and co are so desperate to tie us back in with the EU they will allow themselves to be utterly shafted in any negotiation. It's basically treason.


Exactly, he doesn't care about costs though cause he'll do a Labour typical move and increase the current taxes or invent more ways to tax us,
1
UK/EU negotiations on 18:59 - Nov 11Wingstandwood

UK/EU negotiations on 18:12 - Nov 11 by Dr_Winston

Burnham and co are so desperate to tie us back in with the EU they will allow themselves to be utterly shafted in any negotiation. It's basically treason.


That would be the most worrying thing if the U.K returned to the EU club by having to accept even worse terms and conditions that it had when it was last within the fold.

Having to accept to rules/regulations that no U.K citizen ever voted for, whilst knowing the corrupt shenanigans that goes on in there is sickening.

And then there was reading the 2012 report that Glenys Kinnock was one of 30 British MEPs who were said to regularly turn up to sign an attendance register, claim £175-a-day allowances and leave minutes later.

And then there were 'fact finding' junkets to luxurious destinations to find out about this, that and the other.

And how much was learnt by Glenys Kinnock and Co during a five-day 2006 trip to Barbados that cost taxpayers £200,000 and included a four-hour chartered cruise on a 100ft ship billed as “the longest floating bar in the Caribbean”.

That one was a fact finding mission to find out about poverty apparently. I think the best way to find out about poverty would be to experience it up close and personal in a shanty town as opposed to sipping Piña colada during a 5 star holiday experience?

Argus!

1
UK/EU negotiations on 12:02 - Nov 12Wingstandwood



If accurate and is a 'surrender deal' with £15 billion costs as reported? Hands up who wants to pay more taxes and pay higher bills for household gas and electric, because of?

Argus!

0
UK/EU negotiations on 12:26 - Nov 12KeithHaynes

UK/EU negotiations on 18:12 - Nov 11 by Dr_Winston

Burnham and co are so desperate to tie us back in with the EU they will allow themselves to be utterly shafted in any negotiation. It's basically treason.


It makes you wonder why doesn’t it ?

A great believer in taking anything you like to wherever you want to.
Blog: Would you like to appear here as a Welsh football writer?

0
UK/EU negotiations on 14:35 - Nov 12Whiterockin

UK/EU negotiations on 12:02 - Nov 12 by Wingstandwood



If accurate and is a 'surrender deal' with £15 billion costs as reported? Hands up who wants to pay more taxes and pay higher bills for household gas and electric, because of?


I would be asking who has connections to the 2% of British businesses who would be benefiting.
1
UK/EU negotiations on 15:40 - Nov 12Dr_Winston

UK/EU negotiations on 12:26 - Nov 12 by KeithHaynes

It makes you wonder why doesn’t it ?


The complete disrespect for democracy.

These people would happily suspend it completely if they were sure that "their" sort of Government (a Globalist one) would remain in power.

In their minds People are too stupid to be trusted with the vote. They'll do all sorts of crazy things like demand a reduction in immigration, taxation or net zero policies.

Pain or damage don't end the world. Or despair, or f*cking beatings. The world ends when you're dead. Until then, you got more punishment in store. Stand it like a man... and give some back.

2
UK/EU negotiations on 16:04 - Nov 12JJBomber

UK/EU negotiations on 15:40 - Nov 12 by Dr_Winston

The complete disrespect for democracy.

These people would happily suspend it completely if they were sure that "their" sort of Government (a Globalist one) would remain in power.

In their minds People are too stupid to be trusted with the vote. They'll do all sorts of crazy things like demand a reduction in immigration, taxation or net zero policies.


The Makerfield election proved that people are too stupid to be trusted with the vote!
2
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© FansNetwork 2026